dw.com

60% of German ER Visits Unnecessary, Study Shows

A study of 3500 German health insurance holders found that 60% of emergency room visits were unnecessary, mainly due to difficulties scheduling timely appointments with general practitioners; 58% said they would have avoided the ER with a 48-hour appointment.

Read original article in Polish

Polish

Germany

EconomyHealthGermany HealthcareHealthcare ReformEmergency RoomPrimary Care

Gkv-SpitzenverbandGerman Foundation For Patient Protection

Stefanie Stoff-AhnisEugen BryschKarl Lauterbach

What are the underlying causes contributing to the unnecessary use of emergency room services in Germany?: The study, involving 3500 insured individuals, shows a strong correlation between the inability to schedule timely appointments and unnecessary ER visits. 58% of those who went to the ER stated they would have avoided it with a 40% of respondents admitted to hospital within 12 months, appointment within 48 hours.
What are the immediate consequences of the high number of unnecessary emergency room visits in German hospitals?: A new study reveals that 60% of visits to German hospital emergency rooms were unnecessary, with patients receiving outpatient care suitable for doctor's offices. Many patients (28%) were aware of this, highlighting a critical access issue.
What systemic changes are necessary to address the long-term challenges revealed by the study's findings on healthcare access in Germany?: This points to a systemic failure in German healthcare access. The lack of readily available appointments forces patients to seek emergency care, overwhelming hospitals. Urgent reform is needed to improve primary care access and alleviate ER strain.

Cognitive Concepts

4/5

Framing Bias

The article frames the issue primarily around the misuse of emergency rooms by patients, highlighting statistics on unnecessary visits. This framing could lead readers to blame patients for the burden on the healthcare system, without addressing systemic issues like insufficient healthcare access. The headline, if included, would likely reinforce this framing. The inclusion of quotes from officials further emphasizes this perspective.

2/5

Language Bias

The article uses phrases like "naduszycia" (misuse) and "coś jest nie tak" (something is wrong), which have a negative connotation when describing patient behavior. More neutral language could include phrases like "inappropriate use" or "inefficient use of resources". The overall tone is critical of patients and the lack of sufficient appointments, which could influence readers' perception.

3/5

Bias by Omission

The article focuses on the misuse of emergency rooms, but omits discussion of potential reasons why patients might feel they have no other option, such as a lack of trust in other healthcare providers or fear of high costs. It also doesn't explore the perspective of hospital staff who may be overworked and under-resourced, leading to longer wait times and potentially influencing patient choices. The article mentions a lack of appointment availability as a factor, but this is not explored in detail. The omission of these perspectives could limit the reader's ability to fully understand the issue.

3/5

False Dichotomy

The article presents a false dichotomy by framing the issue as a simple choice between visiting a doctor's office and going to the emergency room. It overlooks the complexities of accessing timely healthcare, such as factors influencing patient decisions beyond the simple availability of appointments. The article does not consider the possibility of patients needing emergency care, but choosing the emergency room due to fears of delay, etc.

Sustainable Development Goals

Good Health and Well-being Positive

Direct Relevance

The study reveals that a significant portion of emergency room visits in German hospitals are avoidable, indicating potential improvements in healthcare resource allocation and patient care. Addressing the root causes, such as limited access to timely appointments with primary care physicians, could significantly reduce unnecessary emergency room visits and improve the efficiency of the healthcare system. This aligns with SDG 3, which aims to ensure healthy lives and promote well-being for all at all ages. The findings suggest improvements in access to primary care and better management of non-emergency health situations could positively impact this goal.

Jan 21, 19:10

German Health Insurance Contributions Projected to Rise Significantly

The IGES Institute forecasts a substantial rise in German health insurance contributions, reaching 18.5% by 2029 and potentially over 22% by 2035 due to rising healthcare costs and an aging population, prompting the DAK health insurance fund to threaten legal action if reforms aren't implemented.

Jan 17, 07:09

German Foot-and-Mouth Disease Outbreak Causes €1 Billion in Losses

A foot-and-mouth disease outbreak in Germany, originating from a virus type traced to Asia, has led to the culling of thousands of animals across affected farms in Brandenburg and resulted in an estimated €1 billion loss for the agricultural sector due to import bans imposed by countries outside the EU, despite the virus presenting minimal risk to humans.

Jan 17, 22:10

Foot-and-Mouth Disease Outbreak in Germany Causes Economic Alarm

Germany's first foot-and-mouth disease outbreak in 35 years has resulted in three buffalo deaths on a Brandenburg farm, prompting concerns about significant economic losses to livestock farming, though the virus is harmless to humans; the Green Week agricultural fair in Berlin canceled live cloven-hoofed animal displays as a precaution.

Jan 15, 07:10

FMD Outbreak in Germany: €1 Billion Export Losses Projected

A foot-and-mouth disease outbreak in a Brandenburg, Germany, buffalo farm has prompted the cancellation of livestock at the Green Week agricultural fair in Berlin and caused import bans from South Korea and the UK, resulting in potential losses of €1 billion in exports to third countries.