theglobeandmail.com
Alberta Judge Recommends Cold-Weather Shelters for Bars After Two Deaths
An Alberta judge recommended that bars implement cold-weather shelters and other measures to prevent alcohol-related hypothermia deaths after two young men died from exposure near a bar in Edmonton.
- What specific actions or lack thereof by the bar and patrons contributed to the deaths?
- Tyler Emes, with a BAC 2.5 times the legal limit, left The Ranch alone, appearing cold and intoxicated shortly after leaving. Mohamed Munyeabdi, with a BAC three times the legal limit, was ejected from The Ranch for intoxication, and was later found deceased after removing his shirt and attempting to enter vehicles in a parking lot. Both deaths highlight a failure of the bar to ensure patron safety.
- What were the key recommendations made by the judge to prevent similar deaths in the future?
- The judge recommended that bars and clubs provide heated outdoor shelters or designated dry-out rooms for intoxicated patrons. Additionally, free coat checks and improved security camera systems were suggested. The Alberta Liquor Authority was urged to establish policies addressing cold weather, hypothermia, and alcohol consumption, including clear definitions for over-serving and safe transport options.
- What broader implications do these deaths and recommendations have for alcohol service and public safety in Alberta?
- These deaths underscore critical gaps in Alberta's liquor regulations regarding cold weather safety and responsible alcohol service. The recommendations could set a precedent for improved patron safety policies at licensed establishments across the province, influencing training, security procedures, and potential liabilities. The need for clear policies on over-serving and safe transport is highlighted.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The article presents a balanced account of the fatality inquiry, detailing the judge's recommendations and the evidence presented. It doesn't overtly favor any particular side, although the tragic nature of the deaths is emphasized, which could be seen as subtly influencing reader sympathy towards the need for change.
Bias by Omission
While the article provides a comprehensive overview of the inquiry, it could benefit from including perspectives from the bar owners beyond their post-incident changes. Additionally, data on the prevalence of similar incidents in other bars could provide broader context and help assess the generalizability of the judge's recommendations. However, given the nature of a fatality inquiry report, the focus on these two specific cases is understandable.
Sustainable Development Goals
The fatality inquiry directly addresses the SDG 3, Good Health and Well-being, by focusing on preventing alcohol-related deaths due to hypothermia. The recommendations aim to reduce preventable deaths and improve the health and safety of bar patrons, aligning with the SDG target of reducing premature mortality from non-communicable diseases.