elmundo.es
Aliança Catalana's Rise in Catalonia: A Survey Reveals Broad Appeal and Divided Views on Independence
A Sigma Dos panel for EL MUNDO shows Aliança Catalana (AC), a far-right Catalan independence party, could win 11-14 seats in the Parlament, drawing support from both pro- and anti-independence voters; however, its voters are almost equally split on independence.
- What is the main finding of the Sigma Dos poll regarding Aliança Catalana's electoral prospects and its voters' stance on independence?
- The poll projects Aliança Catalana to win 11–14 seats in the Catalan Parlament. Crucially, while the party draws support from across the political spectrum, its voter base is nearly evenly split on independence, with 50.8% supporting and 47.7% opposing it.
- How does Aliança Catalana's voter base compare to other Catalan parties regarding their views on independence, and what are the broader implications?
- Unlike other parties, AC attracts voters from both pro- and anti-independence camps. This explains the near-even split among its voters on independence. This contrasts sharply with other independence parties, where significantly higher percentages support independence (Junts per Catalunya 65.6%, CUP 66.3%, ERC 46.7%).
- What factors contribute to Aliança Catalana's electoral success, and what are the potential long-term implications for the Catalan political landscape?
- AC's success stems from its broad appeal, attracting voters disillusioned with the independence process. High voter turnout among its supporters (97% certain to vote) further strengthens its position. This surge could significantly alter the Catalan political landscape, potentially weakening traditional pro-independence parties and further polarizing the debate around independence.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The article frames Aliança Catalana's growth by highlighting its appeal to both pro- and anti-independence voters. The lead focuses on the poll's prediction of significant seat gains, emphasizing the broad base of support. This framing could be seen as downplaying the party's far-right ideology by focusing on its electoral success and broad appeal, rather than its political stances. The inclusion of the referendum results showing a near-even split among AC voters on independence is also a key part of this framing, suggesting a more moderate stance than might be expected.
Language Bias
The article uses terms like "ultraderechista" (far-right) to describe Aliança Catalana, which carries a negative connotation. While factually accurate, this term could influence readers' perceptions. Neutral alternatives could include "extreme-right" or simply describing their policies. The repeated mention of "independentistas" (pro-independence) also shapes the narrative, potentially subtly casting opponents as the default position. Using more neutral terms like "pro-independence" and "pro-union" might mitigate this bias.
Bias by Omission
The article focuses heavily on voting patterns and poll results, but omits analysis of Aliança Catalana's specific policies and platforms. This omission could limit readers' ability to form a complete opinion. The lack of in-depth information about the party's ideology beyond identifying it as "ultraderechista" is also a notable omission. Further, while it mentions the years of the procés, it omits details on major events and government actions to contextualize this process.
False Dichotomy
The article presents a false dichotomy by focusing primarily on the pro-independence versus anti-independence divide, potentially overlooking other relevant political issues and alignments within Catalan society. While independence is a significant issue, framing the entire political landscape around this single axis ignores other potential dimensions of conflict and cooperation among the electorate.
Gender Bias
The article focuses primarily on the party leaders (Sílvia Orriols) and avoids gendered language or stereotypes in its descriptions of political actors and their activities. While the article appropriately focuses on the leader's role, it lacks detailed analysis on gender representation within the party itself or in its policies.
Sustainable Development Goals
The article discusses the rise of Aliança Catalana, a party with a significant portion of voters opposed to Catalan independence. This reflects a potential shift in political landscape towards stability and away from divisive secessionist movements. The high voter turnout intention among Aliança Catalana supporters also suggests a strengthened democratic process. The survey data showing decreasing support for independence contributes to a more stable political environment in Catalonia, aligning with SDG 16 which promotes peaceful and inclusive societies for sustainable development, providing access to justice for all and building effective, accountable and inclusive institutions at all levels.