elpais.com
American Primeval: The Mountain Meadows Massacre
Netflix's "American Primeval" depicts the 1857 Mountain Meadows Massacre in Utah, where 120 settlers were killed by a Mormon militia and Native Americans amid rising tensions between Mormons and the US government, challenging the Church's official narrative.
- What were the immediate consequences of the Mountain Meadows Massacre in 1857, and how did this event shape the relationship between the Mormon community and the US government?
- In 1857 Utah, escalating tensions between Mormons and the US government culminated in the Mountain Meadows Massacre, where 120 settlers were killed by a Mormon militia aided by Native Americans. This event, depicted in Netflix's "American Primeval," highlights the brutal realities of westward expansion and the complex dynamics of power and conflict.
- How did the prior displacement of Mormons from Nauvoo, Illinois, and their subsequent settlement in Utah contribute to the escalating tensions that led to the Mountain Meadows Massacre?
- The series "American Primeval" uses the Mountain Meadows Massacre as a focal point to explore the violent history of westward expansion in Utah during the 1850s. The massacre, perpetrated by a Mormon militia and Native Americans, stemmed from conflict between the Mormons and the US government, illustrating the lawlessness and brutality of the era. The show contrasts the official Mormon narrative with historical evidence suggesting complicity at the highest levels of leadership.
- To what extent does "American Primeval" accurately portray the historical events of the Mountain Meadows Massacre, and what are the implications of its dramatic license for understanding this complex historical episode?
- American Primeval" challenges the sanitized historical narrative surrounding the Mountain Meadows Massacre and Brigham Young's role. By depicting the violence and exploring the motivations behind the attack, the series prompts a critical re-evaluation of this dark chapter in American history. The show's success, despite criticism from the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, signals a growing interest in exploring less-celebrated aspects of the American West.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The article frames the narrative around the brutality of the Mountain Meadows Massacre and the alleged role of Brigham Young, emphasizing the negative aspects of the events and focusing on the violence and its aftermath. The title itself, in the Spanish version, is described as 'edulcorated' compared to the original, highlighting a potential bias in framing the topic. The article uses strong language to describe Brigham Young ('fanático calculador y sin escrúpulos'), setting a negative tone early on. This framing can potentially influence reader perception by focusing on the sensational aspects of the story at the expense of a balanced presentation of historical events.
Language Bias
The article uses loaded language to describe Brigham Young ('fanático calculador y sin escrúpulos'), which carries strong negative connotations and affects the reader's perception. The description of the West as an 'infierno en la tierra' (hell on Earth) also sets a strongly negative tone. More neutral language could be used, such as describing Young's actions as 'controversial' or 'unconventional' instead of using terms that imply inherent moral depravity. The use of 'edulcorated' to describe the Spanish title suggests a bias in tone.
Bias by Omission
The article omits mention of any counterarguments or perspectives from the Mormon Church beyond a quote from a church publication defending Brigham Young's character and motives. The article focuses heavily on the negative portrayal of Young and the massacre, without giving significant space to alternative interpretations or historical nuances presented by the church itself. This omission limits the reader's ability to form a fully informed opinion and understand the complexity of the historical events.
False Dichotomy
The article presents a somewhat simplified dichotomy between the portrayal of Brigham Young as a ruthless, calculating leader and the Mormon Church's attempts to distance itself from the Mountain Meadows Massacre. It doesn't fully explore the internal complexities within the Mormon community at the time or the various motivations and levels of involvement among its members. The narrative leans towards a simplistic view of good versus evil, potentially overlooking nuances in the historical context.
Gender Bias
The article primarily focuses on the actions and roles of male figures (Brigham Young, Jim Bridger, etc.), while the female characters are largely mentioned in relation to their survival or as victims of the massacre. While it mentions the female protagonist and other female survivors, their individual stories are not given detailed treatment compared to the broader narrative. More balanced representation of female experiences in the context of the massacre would enhance the article.
Sustainable Development Goals
The series depicts the Mountain Meadows Massacre, a violent event highlighting the lack of justice and the breakdown of law and order in 19th-century Utah. The conflict between Mormons and the US government, along with the extrajudicial killings, clearly demonstrates a failure of institutions to maintain peace and justice. The depiction of Brigham Young's actions, whether directly ordering the massacre or indirectly inciting it, underscores the negative impact on the establishment of strong institutions and the rule of law.