npr.org
American Primeval: Westward Expansion's Violent Conflicts
American Primeval," a six-episode Netflix miniseries, dramatizes the violent conflicts during westward expansion in the 1850s, incorporating real events like the Mountain Meadows Massacre and featuring characters like Jim Bridger and Brigham Young, highlighting the struggles of pioneers, Native tribes, the army, and Mormon militias.
- How does the series portray the role of the Mormon militia and Brigham Young in the conflicts of the 1850s?
- The show uses actual historical events and characters as a framework for a largely fictional narrative, highlighting the violent clashes over land and resources during westward expansion. The Mountain Meadows Massacre serves as a pivotal plot point, underscoring the brutality of the era and its impact on individuals navigating the treacherous journey west. The series weaves together multiple perspectives, including pioneers, Native tribes, the army, and the Mormon militia, emphasizing the complex and often conflicting interests involved.
- What are the broader implications of "American Primeval's" depiction of violence and the human cost of westward expansion?
- American Primeval" offers a nuanced depiction of westward expansion, exploring its human cost and the multifaceted nature of the conflicts. By focusing on both fictional and real-life events, the series raises questions about land ownership, cultural clashes, and the motivations of different groups. The show's depiction of violence and the struggles faced by individual characters could spark discussions on the legacy of westward expansion and its continuing impact.
- What were the key conflicts and challenges faced by pioneers and other groups during the westward expansion depicted in "American Primeval?
- American Primeval," a new Netflix miniseries, dramatizes the westward expansion of the 1850s, focusing on perilous journeys and conflicts between pioneers, Native tribes, the army, and Mormon militias. The series incorporates real events like the Mountain Meadows Massacre, where 120 pioneers were killed, illustrating the brutal realities of westward expansion. Key characters include Jim Bridger, a trader caught in the conflicts, and Sara Rowell, a woman seeking to reunite with her husband.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The framing is largely positive, emphasizing the strong performances, engaging plot, and cohesive direction. The description of violence as "sudden, chaotic, and disturbing" could be seen as framing this aspect negatively, but overall, the review leans towards a positive presentation of the miniseries.
Language Bias
The language used is largely neutral and descriptive. Terms like "gritty," "full of heart," and "endearing characters" are positive but do not seem overly loaded or biased. The description of the violence is descriptive rather than judgmental.
Bias by Omission
The review focuses heavily on the plot and characters, potentially omitting analysis of underlying themes or historical context related to westward expansion, the treatment of Native Americans, and the role of the Mormon Church. While this is understandable given the space constraints of a radio review, the lack of deeper analysis of these significant issues could be considered a bias by omission.
Sustainable Development Goals
The series depicts the historical injustices and inequalities faced by Native American tribes who were fighting to maintain their land in the face of westward expansion by pioneers, the American Army, and Mormon militias. The conflict highlights the unequal distribution of power and resources, and the dispossession of Indigenous peoples. The Mountain Meadows Massacre, a real-life event depicted in the series, exemplifies the extreme violence and injustice inflicted upon settlers.