elpais.com
American Women Travelers' Unique Perspectives on 19th-Century Spain
Fanny Bullock Workman's 1895 bicycle trip across Spain with her husband, detailed in her book "España en bicicleta," is highlighted in a new research project, "Viajeras estadounidenses explorando España," showcasing the unique perspectives of American women travelers who defied conventions and documented Spain during a period of political change.
- What unique aspects of Fanny Bullock Workman's 1895 bicycle journey across Spain challenged conventional travel patterns of the time and what impact did it have?
- In 1895, Fanny Bullock Workman and her husband William Hunter Workman cycled across Spain, documenting their journey in "España en bicicleta." Their travels, unusual for the time, sparked considerable attention due to their mode of transportation and the female lead.
- How did the socio-political climate in Spain during the late 19th century shape the experiences and perspectives of American female travelers like Fanny Bullock Workman and other authors discussed in the research?
- Their journey highlights the relative inaccessibility of Spain for upper-class American tourists during this period of political change in Spain and negotiation with the US, contrasting with popular European destinations. Bullock Workman's account offers a unique perspective on Spain's landscape and culture, challenging conventional travel narratives of the era.
- What broader implications does the recovery and study of works by American female travelers to Spain during this period have for our understanding of travel literature, gender roles, and the representation of Spain in the late 19th and early 20th centuries?
- The book's rediscovery and inclusion in the "Viajeras estadounidenses explorando España" project sheds light on overlooked female voices in travel writing. This reveals a broader pattern of women challenging societal expectations, documenting their experiences and perspectives in a male-dominated field.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The framing centers on the adventurous and pioneering spirit of American female travelers in Spain, emphasizing their independence and contrasting their experiences with the established 'Grand Tour'. This framing highlights a specific perspective and might overshadow other interpretations of travel to Spain during that period.
Language Bias
The language used is generally neutral and descriptive, avoiding loaded terms. There's an appropriate use of adjectives to convey the experiences of the writers, but no obvious biases in word choice.
Bias by Omission
The article focuses heavily on the experiences of female American writers in Spain, potentially omitting the perspectives of Spanish people and other travelers. While acknowledging limitations of scope, a broader range of voices would enrich the narrative. The article mentions Hemingway's view of bullfighting in contrast to Caroline Earle White's, but lacks a balanced representation of Spanish opinions on the subject.
Gender Bias
The article focuses on female American writers, which, while a valid subject, might perpetuate a gender bias by omitting male counterparts or neglecting to analyze the broader context of gender dynamics in Spain at the time. The article does not exhibit gender bias in its language or descriptions, though.
Sustainable Development Goals
The article highlights the achievements of female American writers who traveled and wrote about Spain between 1880-1936, challenging gender norms of the time by pursuing intellectual and adventurous lives. Their writings offer valuable perspectives on Spanish society and culture, contributing to a more inclusive historical narrative. The focus on women's contributions to literature and travel counters historical biases and promotes gender equality.