nrc.nl
An Unfinished Film": A Poignant Depiction of China's COVID-19 Lockdown
An Unfinished Film", a Chinese movie released this week, offers a poignant portrayal of the COVID-19 pandemic's initial months in Wuhan, blending fiction and real footage to critique the government's response and capture the personal experiences of lockdown, contrasting with other pandemic art's limited success.
- What is the most significant aspect of "An Unfinished Film" concerning its depiction of the COVID-19 pandemic and its impact?
- An Unfinished Film", a Chinese movie, offers a poignant portrayal of the initial COVID-19 pandemic months, contrasting with the limited artistic responses to the crisis. Unlike previous Chinese attempts censored for propaganda, this film uses a blend of fiction and real footage to depict the harsh realities of lockdowns and government control, highlighting individual experiences alongside systemic failures. The film's impact lies in its ability to capture the collective trauma and individual struggles during the pandemic.
- How does the film's approach differ from other artistic representations of the pandemic, and what factors contributed to these differences?
- The film's success stems from its unique approach; it interweaves personal narratives with broader societal critiques of the Chinese government's response to the pandemic. By combining fictional scenes with real-life social media videos and footage from previous works, director Lou Ye creates a powerful reflection of the pandemic's impact on both individuals and the state. This technique effectively conveys the emotional toll of isolation and the chilling effect of state surveillance.
- What are the long-term implications of the film's success in capturing a collective trauma, and what does it suggest about future artistic responses to similar crises?
- An Unfinished Film" suggests a critical trend: artistic responses to global crises often lag, hindered by factors like censorship and the immediate need to address more pressing issues. The film's success in conveying the collective experience of pandemic lockdown challenges this trend, implying future works might better capture such experiences by blending personal narratives with broader societal critiques. The movie's impact on future filmmaking may lie in its demonstration of the effectiveness of this mixed-media approach.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The article clearly frames An Unfinished Film as a superior and unique response to the pandemic in art, praising its depth and ability to capture the collective trauma. This positive framing is evident from the very beginning, describing it as "the most poignant film made about Covid" and "one of the few that truly captures the pandemic." The emphasis on this one film's success may overshadow other artistic expressions, even if unintentionally.
Language Bias
While largely objective, the language used to describe An Unfinished Film is frequently effusive and superlative ("most poignant," "truly captures," "unique combination"). This enthusiastic tone, while understandable given the positive assessment, could be seen as subtly biased and might be toned down for greater neutrality. For example, instead of "most poignant," a more neutral description such as "a powerful portrayal" could be used.
Bias by Omission
The article focuses heavily on Chinese perspectives and experiences of the pandemic, potentially omitting or downplaying the global impact and diverse responses to COVID-19. While acknowledging limitations of space, the lack of comparative analysis across different countries' approaches to the pandemic and their respective artistic outputs could be considered a bias by omission. There is also a lack of discussion on artistic responses outside of film.
False Dichotomy
The article presents a somewhat simplistic dichotomy between superficial, escapist pandemic films and the more profound, critically engaged work of An Unfinished Film. While this contrast is useful for highlighting the film's unique qualities, it might oversimplify the range of artistic responses to the pandemic and neglect films that occupy a middle ground.
Gender Bias
The analysis focuses primarily on male characters and filmmakers (Lou Ye, Xiaorui, Jiang Cheng), with limited discussion of women's experiences during the pandemic, aside from the brief mention of Jiang Cheng's wife. A more balanced representation would include diverse perspectives on gender roles and experiences.
Sustainable Development Goals
The article discusses the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic, highlighting the suffering and loss of life. The film 'An Unfinished Film' portrays the harsh realities of lockdowns, including instances of violence and deaths due to restrictive measures, directly impacting physical and mental well-being. The lack of sufficient artistic response to the pandemic's impact on health is also noted.