theglobeandmail.com
B.C. 2021 Atmospheric River Disaster: Land Use Practices Exacerbated Geohazards
A study found that 46 percent of the landslides, debris flows, and washouts during British Columbia's November 2021 atmospheric river disaster originated in areas logged or burned by wildfires, resulting in five deaths, widespread infrastructure damage, and 18,000 evacuations; the study highlights the need for improved land management practices given the projected increase in extreme weather events.
- What specific impact did land use practices have on the number and severity of geohazards during British Columbia's 2021 atmospheric river disaster?
- In November 2021, British Columbia experienced a devastating atmospheric river disaster resulting in numerous landslides, debris flows, and washouts. A new study reveals that 46 percent of these hazards originated in areas previously logged or burned by wildfires, highlighting the significant role of land use in exacerbating the disaster's impact. This resulted in five deaths, widespread road and bridge destruction, and the evacuation of 18,000 people.
- How did the combination of logging, wildfires, and increased atmospheric river intensity contribute to the extent of the damage and displacement caused by the November 2021 storms?
- The study, published in Earth Surface Processes and Landforms, analyzed 1,360 geohazards across 70,000 square kilometers. It found that 17 percent originated in burned areas, 14 percent near resource roads, and 15 percent in logging cutblocks. These findings underscore the persistent risk associated with resource extraction and wildfire damage, especially given the increased frequency and intensity of atmospheric rivers due to climate change.
- What proactive measures are needed to manage the increased risk of geohazards in British Columbia, considering the projected intensification of both wildfires and atmospheric rivers due to climate change?
- The study's findings indicate a critical need for improved management of resource roads and post-wildfire landscapes to mitigate future geohazard risks in British Columbia. The increasing frequency of intense wildfires and atmospheric rivers, driven by climate change, will likely exacerbate these issues, necessitating proactive measures such as comprehensive road mapping, stability assessments, and improved logging practices to reduce downstream impacts. The fact that nearly half of the resource road failures were from unmapped and presumably unmaintained roads points to a critical gap in current infrastructure management.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The framing emphasizes the role of logging and wildfires in causing landslides, presenting this as a significant contributing factor. While this is supported by the study's findings, the headline and opening paragraphs immediately highlight these factors, potentially shaping reader perception to prioritize this aspect of the story over others. The inclusion of the death toll from one landslide early in the article also emphasizes human tragedy and loss, directly linking it to the logging and wildfire issue.
Language Bias
The language used is largely neutral and factual, although phrases like "severe rains triggered a landslide that killed five people" could be seen as slightly sensationalized. The overall tone is objective, reporting the study's findings without overt emotional language or inflammatory terms.
Bias by Omission
The article focuses heavily on the impact of logging and wildfires on landslides, but omits discussion of other potential contributing factors to the severity of the disaster, such as the intensity and duration of the rainfall, the geological composition of the affected areas, or the effectiveness of existing disaster preparedness measures. While acknowledging the limitations of space, a broader analysis incorporating these factors could offer a more complete understanding. The lack of comment from the Forest and Transportation Ministries is noted, but there is no exploration of the reasons for their non-response or alternative perspectives on the study's findings.
Sustainable Development Goals
The article highlights how logging, wildfires (exacerbated by climate change), and inadequate road maintenance contributed to a significant number of landslides and debris flows during the 2021 atmospheric river disaster in British Columbia. This demonstrates the negative impact of human activities and climate change on environmental stability, aligning directly with the goals of climate action to mitigate climate change impacts and enhance resilience.