nrc.nl
"Buy Now": How Retailers Drive Overconsumption
The Netflix documentary "Buy Now! The Shopping Conspiracy" reveals how retailers use design and marketing to encourage overconsumption, highlighting Amazon's 'buy now' button, the rise of Black Friday, and the impact of planned obsolescence on consumer electronics and clothing.
- What role did the rise of Black Friday and e-commerce play in shaping current consumer habits and fostering a culture of overconsumption?
- The documentary links the rise of Black Friday and e-commerce to increased consumerism. By removing physical barriers and creating a constant sense of "shoppable moments," online retailers foster habitual purchasing. Former Adidas executive Eric Liedtke explains that creating desire, not need, drives sales.
- How do online retailers' design choices, such as Amazon's 'buy now' button, directly impact consumer purchasing behavior and contribute to overconsumption?
- "Buy Now! The Shopping Conspiracy" exposes how retailers manipulate consumers into overconsumption. Amazon's "buy now" button exemplifies this, eliminating critical thinking time by streamlining purchases. The film features former employees revealing design choices meant to maximize impulse buying.
- What are the long-term environmental and societal consequences of business models prioritizing product replacement over durability and repairability, and how can these models be reformed?
- The film highlights the inherent unsustainability of business models dependent on product replacement. Examples like non-replaceable batteries and difficult-to-repair electronics illustrate planned obsolescence. While acknowledging the "right to repair" movement, the documentary focuses on the systemic pressure to prioritize profit over product longevity.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The narrative frames the rise of e-commerce and consumerism primarily as a negative force, driven by corporate greed and manipulative marketing. While it presents some counterpoints, the overall tone emphasizes the downsides and lacks a balanced perspective.
Language Bias
The language used tends to be emotionally charged, using words like "manipulative," "greed," and "tricks." While these terms aren't inherently biased, they contribute to the film's negative framing and could be replaced with more neutral alternatives.
Bias by Omission
The documentary overlooks the positive aspects of e-commerce, such as convenience and access to a wider variety of goods. It also gives short shrift to new regulations regarding the right to repair and focuses more on the negative impacts of consumerism.
False Dichotomy
The film presents a false dichotomy between convenience and conscious consumption, implying that ease of purchase inevitably leads to overconsumption. It doesn't fully explore alternative models that balance convenience with sustainability.
Sustainable Development Goals
The documentary highlights how companies use various tactics to promote overconsumption, impacting sustainable consumption and production patterns. Examples include the ease of online purchasing, planned obsolescence, and misleading recycling symbols. This directly contradicts the SDG's aim for sustainable consumption and production patterns.