theglobeandmail.com
Canada's Court Delays: Justice Denied?
The Canadian justice system faces challenges due to court delays, as exemplified by cases where accused individuals are released due to exceeding time limits set by the R v. Jordan ruling, creating a conflict between the right to a timely trial and justice for victims.
English
Canada
Human Rights ViolationsJustice SystemVictim RightsCourt DelaysCriminal CasesLegal Rulings
Supreme Court Of CanadaOntario Superior Court
Justice Michael CodeJustice Thomas Cromwell
- Why was the Toronto case involving child sexual abuse dismissed?
- Justice Michael Code stayed the Toronto case due to the 31-month delay exceeding the Jordan ruling's 30-month limit for superior courts, even though it involved serious charges of child sexual abuse. This highlights the conflict between the right to a timely trial and justice for victims.
- What data is available on the number of cases stayed due to unreasonable delays?
- Over 400 criminal cases across seven Canadian provinces have been stayed since early 2022 due to unreasonable delays. Ontario saw a more than doubling of such stays between 2017 and 2023, illustrating a systemic issue.
- What solutions are proposed to address the issues arising from the Jordan ruling?
- While the onus is on federal and provincial governments to address court backlogs by increasing resources, the inflexible time limits set by Jordan create a system that releases accused individuals, even in cases of serious crimes, before trial, which erodes public trust in the justice system.
- What are the criticisms of the Jordan ruling's approach to dealing with court delays?
- The Jordan ruling aimed to address a "culture of complacency" towards delays, but its rigid time limits have led to stays in numerous cases, including those involving serious crimes like child sexual abuse. This raises concerns about the balance between the rights of the accused and victims.
- What is the significance of the 2016 R v. Jordan ruling from the Supreme Court of Canada?
- The Supreme Court of Canada's 2016 R v. Jordan ruling set time limits for criminal trials to prevent unreasonable delays. Cases exceeding these limits must be stayed, meaning the accused goes free.