welt.de
Climate Change and Low Farmer Incomes Threaten Ghana's Cocoa Production
Unpredictable weather in West Africa, particularly Ghana, is severely impacting cocoa production, with 13 million diseased cocoa trees cut down in 2024; low farmer income (9% of supermarket price) and high chocolate company profits exacerbate this crisis, potentially leading to cocoa shortages within decades.
- What are the immediate impacts of unpredictable weather and low farmer income on Ghana's cocoa production and the livelihoods of cocoa farmers?
- Ghana's cocoa production is threatened by unpredictable weather, leading to a 13 million cocoa tree loss in 2024. This has caused farmers to earn less than half of what they need to survive, impacting their ability to replace aging trees, a process taking up to five years. The low prices paid to farmers, only 9 percent of the supermarket price, further exacerbate the issue.
- How do the prices paid to cocoa farmers compare to the final retail price, and what role does this price disparity play in the current challenges facing the industry?
- Unstable weather patterns in West Africa, a major cocoa producing region, combined with low farmer incomes and the long time needed to replace cocoa trees, create a vulnerable cocoa supply chain. This vulnerability is heightened by the fact that cocoa farmers receive only a small fraction of the final product's value, while companies like Lindt & Sprüngli report significant profits. The EU deforestation regulation further limits options for expansion.
- What are the long-term implications of climate change, low farmer incomes, and potential cocoa substitutes for the future of the cocoa industry and chocolate consumption?
- The cocoa industry faces a potential crisis within 20-30 years, as climate change makes cocoa cultivation increasingly difficult in West Africa. While sustainability programs exist, they are insufficient to address the fundamental issues of low farmer income and price volatility. The industry's response of potentially substituting cocoa butter with other oils highlights the risk of declining cocoa quality and potentially impacting consumer preferences.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The framing emphasizes the negative consequences of climate change and low farmer incomes, potentially eliciting sympathy for farmers and concern about the future of chocolate. The use of phrases like "ruin the harvest," "unpredictable weather," and "erschreckendes Szenario" (frightening scenario) contributes to this negative framing. While acknowledging industry efforts, the focus remains primarily on the problems rather than comprehensive solutions or industry efforts beyond a few sustainability programs.
Language Bias
The article uses emotionally charged language, such as "ruin the harvest" and "erschreckendes Szenario," which can evoke strong negative emotions in the reader. Other examples include describing the situation as "unberechenbar" (unpredictable) and emphasizing the dramatic potential loss of cocoa from West Africa. More neutral alternatives could include "challenging weather patterns", "significant price disparities", and "potential changes to cocoa production".
Bias by Omission
The article focuses heavily on the challenges faced by cocoa farmers in Ghana, but omits discussion of similar challenges or potential solutions in other cocoa-producing regions. While mentioning Ivory Coast as another major supplier, it lacks a comparative analysis of the situation there. The article also doesn't explore potential alternative sourcing strategies beyond replacing cocoa butter, such as exploring different cocoa varieties more resilient to climate change or investing in research and development for improved farming techniques more broadly.
False Dichotomy
The article presents a somewhat simplistic eitheor scenario: either cocoa production continues as is, with the potential for severe consequences, or manufacturers resort to using substitute ingredients. It doesn't fully explore the numerous intermediate solutions or policy interventions that could be implemented to address the challenges of cocoa production, such as farmer support programs, sustainable farming practices, or fair trade initiatives.
Sustainable Development Goals
The article highlights that Ghanaian cocoa farmers earn less than half of what they need to survive, indicating a negative impact on poverty reduction. The low prices paid to farmers, despite the high cost of chocolate, exacerbate their economic hardship and hinder their ability to escape poverty.