dw.com
"Conclave": Papal Intrigue and Moral Dilemmas in Berger's New Film
"Conclave," a new film by Edward Berger, premiered at Telluride and Toronto, skipping Venice; it features a meticulously recreated Sistine Chapel, exploring a papal conclave with political intrigue and moral dilemmas mirroring Agatha Christie mysteries.
- What is the central conflict driving the narrative of "Conclave," and how does the setting contribute to this conflict?
- "Conclave," a new film by Edward Berger, premiered at the Telluride Film Festival and Toronto Film Festival, but notably skipped the Venice Film Festival. The film, set during a papal conclave, features a meticulous recreation of the Sistine Chapel. Political maneuvering and the search for the next Pope are central themes.
- How does the film's structure and visual style reflect its thematic concerns, and what is the impact of this stylistic choice?
- The film's structure mirrors Agatha Christie's crime novels, with the conclave's isolated setting creating a closed environment similar to a locked-room mystery. Cardinal Thomas Lawrence, akin to Hercule Poirot, investigates the candidates, uncovering compromising information on each.
- What broader implications about power, morality, and fate does "Conclave" suggest, and how does this relate to Berger's previous work?
- Berger's directorial focus on action over character development creates a certain emotional distance. While visually stunning, this approach contrasts with the film's exploration of moral dilemmas and the burden of choice, potentially diminishing the emotional impact for the viewer. The film explores the theme that even powerful individuals remain subject to the forces beyond their control.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The review frames the film's reception and critical response through the lens of its exclusion from the Venice Film Festival. This choice emphasizes a potential slight against the film, potentially overlooking other positive critical responses or the film's overall success in other festivals. The review also prioritizes the director's previous work, "All Quiet on the Western Front," using it as a point of comparison to highlight both similarities and differences in style, potentially influencing the reader's perception of "Conclave."
Language Bias
The language used is generally neutral, though descriptive words like "cold intonation" and "emotional detachment" subtly shape the reader's perception of the film's style. While these are valid observations, they lack balanced counterpoints. More objective terms like "reserved style" or "contained emotional expression" might be considered.
Bias by Omission
The review focuses heavily on the film's production and directorial choices, neglecting detailed analysis of the plot, characters' motivations, or the film's overall message. While it mentions the film's thematic concerns, it lacks a deeper exploration of how effectively these themes are presented or explored within the narrative. The omission of specific plot points and character development limits the ability to fully assess the film's strengths and weaknesses.
False Dichotomy
The review presents a somewhat false dichotomy by contrasting the director's focus on detail with a perceived lack of human warmth, suggesting these are mutually exclusive. It's possible to have both meticulous detail and emotional depth in a film. The review doesn't fully consider alternative interpretations of the director's style.
Sustainable Development Goals
The film depicts a conclave, the process of electing a new pope, highlighting the importance of strong institutions and fair processes in leadership selection within the Catholic Church. The internal conflicts and power dynamics within the Church are explored, indirectly touching upon themes of justice and accountability.