dw.com
Dutch Court Overturns Shell Emission Ruling
A Dutch appeals court overturned a landmark ruling ordering Shell to reduce emissions, sparking debate over corporate climate responsibility.
Portuguese
Germany
JusticeGermany Energy SecurityLawsuitClimateOilEmissions
ShellFriends Of The Earth NetherlandsOil Change InternationalUrgewaldGlobal Witness
Donald PolsWael SawanRoger CoxNine De Pater
- What was Shell's response to the appeals court's decision?
- Shell's CEO, Wael Sawan, deemed the decision positive for the global energy transition, the Netherlands, and Shell itself. However, environmental groups criticized Shell for not complying with the original ruling and expanding its oil and gas exploration.
- What was significant about the original 2021 court ruling against Shell?
- The 2021 ruling was a landmark decision as it was the first time a court ordered a large corporation to comply with the Paris Agreement. It established a precedent for holding private companies responsible for climate targets.
- How did Friends of the Earth Netherlands react to the appeals court's ruling?
- Friends of the Earth Netherlands, which brought the initial lawsuit, expressed mixed feelings. While disappointed, they highlighted the case's impact in holding major polluters accountable and fostering climate change discussions.
- What was the outcome of the Dutch appeals court's decision regarding Shell's emission reduction targets?
- A Dutch appeals court overturned a 2021 ruling that ordered Shell to cut its carbon emissions by 45% by 2030. The court agreed that climate protection is a human right but stated that Shell has the right to decide how to achieve emission reductions.
- In light of recent climate reports, what is the broader significance of the ongoing legal battle over Shell's emissions?
- The UN's State of the Climate report highlighted 2024 as the hottest year on record, emphasizing the urgency of emission cuts. Despite this, many oil and gas companies are still expanding exploration activities.