dw.com
El Salvador: Seven El Faro Journalists Exiled After Reporting on Bukele-Gang Pact
In May 2025, El Salvador's El Faro newspaper published gang leaders' claims of a pact between President Nayib Bukele and gangs, resulting in arrest warrants for seven journalists now exiled due to the risk of imprisonment and torture in El Salvador, where President Bukele is accused of silencing dissent and consolidating power.
- What are the long-term implications of the government's actions against El Faro for the future of democracy, press freedom, and human rights in El Salvador?
- The crackdown on El Faro and other critical voices in El Salvador signals a significant erosion of democratic institutions. The increasing authoritarianism, coupled with the government's control over the justice system and its apparent disregard for due process, suggests that the space for independent journalism and opposition politics in El Salvador is rapidly shrinking, potentially leading to further human rights abuses and a decline in democratic accountability. The ongoing state of exception allows for the imprisonment of almost 80,000 people, largely accused of gang affiliation, further illustrating the repression.
- What are the immediate consequences of El Faro's reporting on President Bukele's alleged pact with gangs, and how does this affect press freedom in El Salvador?
- El Faro", a Salvadoran digital newspaper, published revelations in May 2025 from two gang leaders claiming President Nayib Bukele secured power through a pact with gangs. This led to arrest warrants for seven El Faro journalists now outside the country, unable to return due to the threat of arrest and potential torture. The government's actions, while denying any wrongdoing, directly target journalists rather than the gang leaders who provided the information.
- How does the Bukele government's response to El Faro's reporting reflect broader trends of authoritarianism and repression in El Salvador, and what role does the state of exception play?
- The government's actions against El Faro journalists are part of a broader pattern of repression against critical press in El Salvador under President Bukele. This follows earlier government surveillance of El Faro and other human rights defenders, using Pegasus software, and the subsequent financial audits that forced El Faro to relocate its fiscal headquarters. This pattern demonstrates a systemic effort to silence dissent and consolidate power.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The article frames the narrative predominantly from the perspective of the journalists from El Faro, highlighting their fear, uncertainty, and the government's repressive actions. Headlines and the introduction emphasize the threats and persecution faced by the journalists, potentially shaping the reader's perception of Bukele's government as solely oppressive.
Language Bias
The article uses strong and emotive language like "dictatorship," "repress," "persecution," and "intimidation." While these terms accurately reflect the described situation, they could be replaced with more neutral alternatives such as 'authoritarian regime,' 'crackdown,' 'harassment,' and 'pressure' to ensure more balanced reporting. The repeated use of "Bukele" as a subject creates a narrative that casts him as the primary antagonist.
Bias by Omission
The article focuses heavily on the government's actions and the journalists' experiences, but omits details about the specific content of the leaked information from gang leaders. While mentioning the claims involved a pact between Bukele and gangs, the exact nature of this pact and supporting evidence are not elaborated upon. This omission leaves the reader with an incomplete picture of the accusations against Bukele and limits their ability to form a fully informed opinion.
False Dichotomy
The article presents a somewhat simplistic dichotomy between Bukele's government and the journalists, portraying a clear conflict between 'dictatorship' and 'independent journalism'. It doesn't fully explore potential nuances or alternative interpretations of the situation, such as considering if there might be other factors influencing the events beyond a simple authoritarian crackdown.
Sustainable Development Goals
The article details the persecution of journalists from El Faro, highlighting the erosion of press freedom and the rule of law in El Salvador under President Bukele's administration. The government's actions, including issuing arrest warrants for journalists who reported on alleged government corruption and pacts with gangs, directly undermine the principles of justice, accountability, and freedom of expression. This creates a climate of fear, impedes the ability of journalists to hold power accountable, and severely weakens democratic institutions.