nrc.nl
England Lionesses Stand Against Online Racism, Abandon Kneeling Ritual
The English women's football team stood instead of kneeling before their Euro semi-final match due to the diminishing impact of the anti-racism gesture and following online racist abuse against player Jessica Carter, highlighting the need for systemic change to combat online hate in women's sports.
- How does the online racist abuse faced by Jessica Carter illustrate the broader challenges of combating online hate in women's sports?
- The English Lionesses' decision to forgo their pre-match kneeling highlights the evolving nature of symbolic protests against racism. While initially impactful, the gesture's effectiveness has waned, underscoring the need for systemic change to combat online hate and discrimination. This is further evidenced by a FIFA study revealing a 29% higher incidence of online hate toward women footballers compared to men.
- What prompted the English women's football team to abandon their pre-match kneeling ritual, and what are the immediate implications of this decision?
- Following the death of George Floyd, the English women's football team initiated a ritual of kneeling before matches to protest racism. However, they stood during their recent Euro semi-final, citing the gesture's diminished impact and the need for more substantial anti-racism efforts. This decision followed online racist abuse targeting player Jessica Carter, prompting her temporary social media withdrawal and police involvement.
- What systemic factors contribute to the disproportionate level of online hate targeting women athletes, and what comprehensive strategies are needed to address this issue effectively?
- The incident reveals a critical gap between symbolic gestures and tangible action in addressing online racism against female athletes. The increasing popularity of women's sports, coupled with the financial disparities between men's and women's leagues, exacerbates the problem. This necessitates a multi-pronged approach that includes stronger regulations, increased financial support for women's sports, and a societal shift in attitudes toward gender equality.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The narrative prioritizes the story of the English women's football team's decision to stop kneeling and the subsequent online racist abuse directed at Jessica Carter. While this is a significant event, the framing might overshadow other important aspects of the fight against racism in football, such as systemic inequalities and lack of resources.
Language Bias
The language used is generally neutral and objective. However, phrases like "online hate" and "hate messages" are used repeatedly, which although factually accurate, could be considered somewhat loaded. More specific descriptions of the abuse could provide a more impactful narrative without resorting to emotionally charged language.
Bias by Omission
The article focuses heavily on the response to online racism faced by English female footballers, particularly the decision to stop kneeling before matches. While it mentions the broader issue of racism in football, it could benefit from a more in-depth exploration of systemic racism within the sport and society at large. The article also lacks specific examples of the racist abuse received by Jess Carter, relying instead on general statements from the FA and the player herself. This omission limits the reader's understanding of the nature and severity of the abuse.
False Dichotomy
The article doesn't present a false dichotomy in the strict sense of an oversimplified eitheor choice. However, it implicitly suggests that kneeling is the only way to combat racism, while also highlighting its diminishing effectiveness. This could be interpreted as presenting a limited view of the available methods to tackle the problem.
Gender Bias
The article highlights the disproportionate online hate faced by women footballers, particularly women of color. It mentions that women in sports often face a double burden of sexism and racism. The inclusion of perspectives from various women in the field strengthens the analysis and avoids perpetuating stereotypes.
Sustainable Development Goals
The article highlights the disproportionate amount of online hate faced by female soccer players, particularly those who are Black or from minority groups. This demonstrates a clear lack of gender equality within the sports industry, where women athletes are subjected to abuse and discrimination not faced to the same extent by their male counterparts. The unequal pay also contributes to the issue, as women athletes may rely more heavily on social media for sponsorships, making them more vulnerable to online attacks.