dw.com
EU Parliamentarians Urge Greece to Halt Tanker Sales to Russia's 'Shadow Fleet'
Members of the European Parliament's "Friends of European Ukraine" group urged Greek PM Mitsotakis to stop the sale of Greek ships to Russia's "shadow fleet," which circumvents sanctions, endangering Europe's security and environment; a Brookings study revealed that Greek shipowners sold 37% of the 75% of sanctioned tankers in the fleet, earning approximately $4 billion.
- What specific actions are being demanded from Greece to counter Russia's use of a "shadow fleet" of tankers, and what are the immediate consequences of inaction?
- Over 30 members of the European Parliament's informal "Friends of European Ukraine" group urged Greek Prime Minister Kyriakos Mitsotakis to prevent further sales of Greek vessels to Russian entities or those suspected of collaborating with Russia. This follows a Brookings Institution study revealing that Greek shipowners sold a significant portion of tankers now forming Russia's "shadow fleet," which circumvents sanctions and funds the war in Ukraine.
- How does the involvement of Greek shipowners contribute to Russia's ability to circumvent sanctions, and what are the broader economic and geopolitical implications?
- The "shadow fleet," comprising around 600 tankers, enables Russia to sell energy resources above the G7 price cap, generating billions of euros for its military. This fleet utilizes transshipment points near Greece to obscure the oil's origin, posing environmental and security risks.
- What are the systemic weaknesses in current sanctions enforcement that allow the continued operation of the Russian "shadow fleet," and what stronger measures could be implemented to effectively mitigate this threat?
- The EU's sanctions, including monitoring and blacklisting of vessels, aim to increase the costs for Russia. However, the continued involvement of Greek shipowners highlights the challenge of fully preventing the circumvention of sanctions and underscores the need for stronger international cooperation to address this issue. The long-term implications include the potential for further escalation of the conflict and continued environmental damage.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The headline and introductory paragraphs immediately frame the issue as a problem caused by Greece's potential complicity in circumventing sanctions. This sets a critical tone and directs the reader's attention toward the culpability of Greek actors, potentially overshadowing other contributing factors or mitigating circumstances. The repeated use of terms such as "tеневой флот" (shadow fleet) and "экологическая бомба" (ecological bomb) contributes to this framing.
Language Bias
The language used is largely factual but contains charged terms like "tеневой флот" (shadow fleet), "экологическая бомба" (ecological bomb), and descriptions emphasizing the negative impacts on Ukraine. While these terms are not inherently biased, their usage contributes to the overall negative framing of Greece's role. Neutral alternatives could include more descriptive phrasing like 'fleet engaged in sanctions circumvention' and 'potential environmental risks'.
Bias by Omission
The article focuses heavily on the accusations against Greek ship owners and the actions of the EU, but omits perspectives from the Greek government, Greek ship owners themselves, or other relevant stakeholders. While acknowledging the Brookings Institution report, alternative viewpoints or data challenging these findings are absent. This lack of balanced representation could limit the reader's ability to form a complete understanding of the issue.
False Dichotomy
The article presents a somewhat simplistic eitheor framing: either Greece actively prevents the sale of ships to Russia, or it allows the continuation of activities contributing to the war effort. More nuanced possibilities, such as the complexities of international maritime law or the economic pressures on Greek ship owners, are largely ignored.
Sustainable Development Goals
The sale of Greek tankers to the Russian shadow fleet contributes to the financing of Russia's war in Ukraine, undermining peace and security. The actions of Greek shipowners directly support the Russian military effort, violating international sanctions and norms.