elpais.com
Excess and Power in the History of Celebration
Carmen Morán's "La belleza de las fiestas" examines the history of celebration, tracing common threads from Roman banquets to Andy Warhol's Factory parties, revealing how excess and displays of power are central to the ritual.
- How do power structures and social status manifest in historical celebrations, and what role does extravagance play in these displays?
- Morán's work connects historical celebrations, from Roman banquets to Andy Warhol's Factory parties, highlighting consistent themes of excess in food, drink, and spectacle. This excess, she argues, is integral to the celebratory experience, a ritualistic release.
- What are the key characteristics of human celebration across different historical periods, and what are the common threads connecting them?
- Human beings universally celebrate, engaging in rituals of excess involving music, alcohol, dance, and conversation—moments devoid of practical utility yet possessing cathartic and subversive qualities. Carmen Morán's book, "La belleza de las fiestas," explores this, detailing memorable historical celebrations.
- What are the potential consequences of unrestrained excess in celebrations, and how do these consequences shape the nature of future festivities?
- The book suggests future implications by analyzing how power dynamics influence celebrations, from royal feasts to exclusive modern events. The inherent risk of excess, leading to consequences like Fouquet's downfall, remains a constant undercurrent in the history of celebration.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The framing emphasizes the excessive and celebratory aspects of festivals, potentially downplaying any negative consequences or societal impacts. The focus on extravagant historical examples might overshadow more modest or community-based celebrations.
Language Bias
The language used is generally neutral and descriptive. However, terms like "despilfarro" (extravagance) and "excesos" (excesses) are repeated, potentially subtly influencing the reader's perception towards a positive view of excessive celebration. More neutral terms like "generous spending" or "lavish displays" could be used.
Bias by Omission
The article focuses heavily on Western celebrations and historical examples, potentially omitting relevant perspectives from other cultures and historical periods. While acknowledging limitations of space, a broader geographical and historical representation would enhance the analysis.