english.elpais.com
Far-Right Rise in Europe Linked to Deficit in Nazi Past Confrontation
Nationalist-populist parties AfD and FPÖ gained significant ground in recent German and Austrian elections, particularly in East Germany and Austria, regions that historically avoided confronting their Nazi past; this success is linked to a deficit in historical memory compared to West Germany.
- How do the distinct historical narratives in East Germany and Austria concerning National Socialism explain the varying levels of success for far-right parties?
- The success of far-right parties in East Germany and Austria is correlated with a less critical engagement with the Nazi past compared to West Germany. Sociologist Rainer Lepsius's work highlights how these regions 'externalized' the memory of National Socialism. This difference in historical awareness has influenced political culture, contributing to the rise of parties exploiting resentment towards the remembrance process.
- What is the immediate impact of the far-right's electoral success in East Germany and Austria, considering their differing approaches to confronting their Nazi past?
- In the recent German (February 23rd) and Austrian (September 29th) elections, nationalist-populist parties like AfD and FPÖ achieved significant success, particularly in former East Germany and Austria. AfD won 34% of the vote in eastern Germany, while FPÖ secured 28.8% in Austria. This success is linked to these regions' historical avoidance of confronting their Nazi past, contrasting with West Germany's extensive engagement with this history.
- What are the potential future implications of the weakening 'cordon sanitaire' in Germany and the broader erosion of historical memory concerning the Nazi past in Europe?
- The dissolving border of memory, separating nations confronting their Nazi past from those who haven't, threatens to normalize far-right successes. While the 'cordon sanitaire' remains in Germany, its potential breakdown, especially in East German parliaments, poses a significant risk. The rise of AfD in West Germany, despite its origins in the East, underscores the expanding reach of this phenomenon and the potential for its spread to other European nations.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The narrative frames the rise of far-right parties as directly linked to a lack of historical reckoning with Nazism, presenting this as a primary, if not sole, causal factor. This emphasis might lead readers to overlook other important contributing factors. The use of phrases like "landslide" and "hegemonic" when describing AfD's success in East Germany contributes to this framing.
Language Bias
The article uses strong language, such as "far right," "radicalizing its discourse," and "full-blown correction," which carry negative connotations. While descriptive, these terms could be replaced with more neutral alternatives, such as "nationalist parties," "evolving discourse," and "significant shift." The repeated use of "landslide" and "hegemonic" could also be toned down to convey a similar meaning without as much charged language.
Bias by Omission
The article focuses heavily on the relationship between historical memory of Nazism and the rise of far-right parties in Germany and Austria, but omits discussion of other contributing factors to the success of these parties, such as economic inequality, social anxieties, and broader European political trends. While the connection drawn is insightful, the exclusive focus risks oversimplification and a misleading narrative.
False Dichotomy
The article presents a somewhat simplistic dichotomy between West Germany's intensive confrontation with its Nazi past and the more externalized approach in East Germany and Austria. This framing neglects the nuances within each region and the complexities of historical memory and political identity.
Gender Bias
The article focuses primarily on male political figures (e.g., Herbert Kickl, Elon Musk), although it mentions Alice Weidel. While not overtly biased, the disproportionate focus on men might subtly reinforce existing power dynamics and underrepresent women's roles in the far-right movements.
Sustainable Development Goals
The rise of far-right parties in Germany and Austria, fueled by a lack of historical reckoning with Nazism, undermines democratic institutions and social cohesion. The rhetoric employed by these parties, echoing past injustices, threatens peace and fuels intolerance.