elpais.com
Futile Wars: The Hundred Years' War and the Crusades
The Hundred Years' War (1337-1453) and the Crusades (1096-1291) were protracted conflicts resulting in millions of deaths and minimal territorial changes, highlighting the devastating human cost of unresolved conflicts.
- What were the primary consequences of the Hundred Years' War, and how did its human cost compare to its territorial gains?
- The Hundred Years' War (1337-1453), lasting 116 years and fought primarily in France, resulted in no territorial changes despite the death of 2.3 to 3.3 million people. The conflict, spanning at least four generations, began with the French King seizing Gascony from England, leading to protracted warfare that ultimately left the territorial status quo unchanged. This highlights the devastating human cost of prolonged conflict with minimal tangible gain.
- How do the causes and consequences of the Hundred Years' War compare to those of the Crusades, and what broader patterns of conflict do they reveal?
- The Hundred Years' War's futility underscores the devastating consequences of prolonged conflict. The war's immense human cost (2.3-3.3 million deaths) contrasts sharply with its lack of significant territorial changes, demonstrating the senselessness of protracted warfare. This pattern mirrors the Crusades (1096-1291), another protracted conflict lasting 195 years, resulting in similar futility despite immense casualties (2-6 million Christian deaths).
- What parallels exist between the Hundred Years' War and the Crusades, and what insights do these conflicts offer regarding the resolution of protracted conflicts like the Israeli-Palestinian conflict?
- The Hundred Years' War and the Crusades serve as cautionary tales of the devastating human and societal costs of protracted conflict, with limited territorial gains despite millions of deaths. The comparison with the ongoing Israeli-Palestinian conflict highlights the potential for such conflicts to become entrenched, causing immense suffering without achieving lasting resolution. The lack of decisive outcomes suggests a systemic failure in conflict resolution mechanisms.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The framing emphasizes the negative aspects—the duration, death toll, and perceived futility—of the Hundred Years' War and the Crusades. The author's concluding comparison to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict further reinforces this negative framing, suggesting a parallel of pointless violence. The selection of Joan of Arc's tragic death as an example amplifies the emotional impact of the negative framing.
Language Bias
The text employs highly charged and negative language such as "pesadilla" (nightmare), "malísima suerte" (very bad luck), "brutal," "patética" (pathetic), and "inútil" (useless) to describe the wars. This emotionally charged language influences the reader's perception, making it difficult to form a balanced understanding of the historical events.
Bias by Omission
The text focuses heavily on the death tolls and futility of the Hundred Years' War and the Crusades, but omits discussion of potential political, social, or economic consequences or changes that may have resulted from these conflicts, even if unintended or long-term. It also doesn't consider the perspectives of those who participated in or were affected by the wars, beyond a brief mention of Joan of Arc.
False Dichotomy
The narrative presents a false dichotomy by framing both the Hundred Years' War and the Crusades as entirely 'useless' and solely characterized by death and destruction. This ignores the complex historical contexts, political motivations, and societal impacts of these events.
Gender Bias
The only specific individual mentioned is Joan of Arc, highlighting her death in a gruesome way. While this is undeniably a significant historical event, the lack of similar details about other figures (especially male figures) involved suggests a potential gender bias in the selection of examples to illustrate the suffering caused by war.
Sustainable Development Goals
The article details the Hundred Years