zeit.de
German Colonial Atrocity: The Killing of Sultan Mkwawa and the Repatriation of Human Remains
The killing of Sultan Mkwawa of the Hehe people by German colonial troops in 1898 in Tanzania, the removal of his skull as a trophy, and the subsequent repatriation efforts highlight the brutality of German colonialism and ongoing efforts to address historical injustices.
- What were the immediate consequences of the killing of Sultan Mkwawa and the removal of his skull?
- In 1898, German colonial troops killed Sultan Mkwawa of the Hehe people in Tanzania and decapitated him. His skull was taken to Germany as a trophy and for anthropological study. This act symbolized the culmination of a brutal seven-year war.
- How did the German colonial war against the Hehe people contribute to the larger context of German colonial expansion in East Africa?
- The taking of Mkwawa's skull represents the broader context of German colonial atrocities in East Africa. The Hehe's resistance, culminating in this event, highlights the violent nature of colonial expansion and the disregard for indigenous lives and cultural heritage. The removal of the skull was not an isolated incident but part of a pattern of grave robbing and the appropriation of human remains.
- What are the long-term implications of the repatriation of human remains from German institutions, and what further steps might be taken to address colonial injustices?
- The eventual return of a skull (possibly Mkwawa's) to Tanzania in 1954, and the 2019 repatriation of twelve other skulls from the Charité hospital in Berlin, signals a shift in acknowledging past colonial injustices. Further research into the provenance of human remains in German institutions could lead to more repatriations and a deeper understanding of colonial violence.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The narrative structure emphasizes the German actions and perspectives, particularly in the early sections. The beheading of Mkwawa and the subsequent German celebrations are vividly described, setting a tone that centers on the German perspective. While the Hehe resistance is acknowledged, the framing tends to highlight German actions as the driving force of the narrative. The headline (if any) would heavily influence this framing bias.
Language Bias
The language used is mostly neutral in describing events, although the description of the German soldiers' joy at Mkwawa's death and the quotes from Magdalene Prince's diary could be seen as emotionally charged. The use of words like "macabre" in relation to the beheading and skull could be seen as subtly loaded. More neutral alternatives could be employed to describe the events objectively.
Bias by Omission
The article focuses heavily on the German perspective and actions during the colonial war, giving less attention to the Hehe perspective beyond their resistance and losses. While the Hehe's perspective is partially represented through Mkwawa's actions and the ultimate repatriation of remains, a deeper exploration of their culture, motivations, and societal structures beyond the war would provide a more balanced account. The motivations of individual German soldiers beyond ambition and orders are not explored. The article also omits details about the long-term consequences of the colonial war on the Hehe people and the region.
False Dichotomy
The narrative presents a somewhat simplified dichotomy between German colonial power and Hehe resistance. The complexities of collaboration, internal divisions within the Hehe, and the nuanced motivations of individuals on both sides are not fully explored. This simplifies the historical events and may present a less-nuanced understanding of the conflict.
Gender Bias
The article does not show significant gender bias. While women are mentioned (Magdalene Prince's diary entry), their roles are limited to the context of the war. There is no evidence of gender stereotyping or disproportionate focus on gender-related details.
Sustainable Development Goals
The article describes the violent colonial actions of German forces in Tanzania, including warfare, destruction of villages, and the killing of civilians. This directly contradicts the principles of peace, justice, and strong institutions, highlighting the negative impact of colonialism on these principles. The taking of Mkwawa