sueddeutsche.de
German Court Reviews Solidarity Surcharge Constitutionality
The German Constitutional Court is reviewing the constitutionality of the solidarity surcharge, a tax imposed to finance German reunification. The FDP challenges its continued existence, while the government argues that the financial need persists.
German
Germany
PoliticsGermany Labour MarketFinanceTaxationConstitutionGerman Law
BundesverfassungsgerichtFdpBundesregierungDeutsches Institut Für Wirtschaftsforschung (Diw)Leibniz-Institut Für Wirtschaftsforschung Halle
Doris KönigHenning BergerKyrill-Alexander SchwarzMichael SchrodiAndreas AudretschRhona FetzerReint GroppFlorian ToncarKatja Hessel
- What is the role and significance of the DIW study in this case?
- A 2020 DIW study estimated continued reunification-related burdens on the federal budget until 2030, which the government uses to support its argument. However, critics argue the study lacks sufficient evidence.
- What is the main legal issue being debated in the German Federal Constitutional Court?
- The German Federal Constitutional Court is reviewing the constitutionality of the solidarity surcharge (Soli), a tax levied to finance German reunification.
- What is the primary argument of the FDP politicians challenging the solidarity surcharge?
- The FDP politicians argue that the Soli is unconstitutional since the end of Solidarpakt II in 2019, as its original purpose no longer applies and it creates unequal treatment.
- How does the German government justify the continued existence of the solidarity surcharge?
- The German government defends the Soli, arguing that reunification continues to necessitate additional funding and citing ongoing financial obligations.
- What are the potential financial implications if the court declares the solidarity surcharge unconstitutional?
- If the court rules against the Soli, the German government would need to find alternative funding sources for the roughly €12.75 billion currently generated annually, and potentially repay billions in past collections.