lemonde.fr

Graphic Novel "Ressources" Details Unsustainable Resource Extraction and Promotes Techno-Discernment

Philippe Bihouix and Vincent Perriot's "Ressources. Un défi pour l'humanité" details the unsustainable rate of resource extraction, criticizing technosolutionism and advocating for "techno-discernment" to achieve a sustainable future, highlighting that more resources will be extracted in the next 30 years than in all of human history.

Read original article in French

French

France

EconomyScienceEconomic GrowthSustainabilityBook ReviewResource DepletionTechnology LimitsLow-Tech

CastermanSeuilDargaudSilicon Valley

Philippe BihouixVincent PerriotElon MuskJeff BezosJean-Marc JancoviciChristophe BlainJacques Ellul

How does the graphic novel critique the technosolutionist approach, and what alternative solutions are proposed?: The graphic novel critiques the technosolutionist approach of Silicon Valley giants who see space expansion as a solution to resource depletion. It also examines the limits of technological solutions such as nuclear fusion and artificial intelligence in addressing ecological crises. The authors argue that the dematerialization of the economy has reduced our understanding of resource consumption.
What are the long-term implications of our current consumption patterns, and how can techno-discernment contribute to a sustainable future?: Bihouix proposes "techno-discernment," advocating for a deeper understanding of our needs and identifying areas where we can reduce consumption. This approach, inspired by Jacques Ellul, suggests a sustainable future that is not solely reliant on technological advancements but also considers social and environmental impacts. The book encourages a critical analysis of economic growth and its reliance on finite resources.
What are the immediate consequences of the current unsustainable rate of resource extraction, and how do these impacts affect global systems?: Philippe Bihouix and Vincent Perriot's graphic novel, "Ressources. Un défi pour l'humanité," uses a dialogue format to explain complex concepts related to resource depletion. The authors highlight the unsustainable rate of resource extraction, emphasizing that we will extract more resources in the next 30 years than since the dawn of humanity. This will lead to increased pollution, deforestation, and toxic waste.

Cognitive Concepts

2/5

Framing Bias

The review frames the book very positively, highlighting its accessibility, clarity, and intellectual richness. While this is largely justified, the overwhelmingly positive tone might overshadow potential shortcomings or limitations of the book's arguments.

1/5

Language Bias

The language used is largely neutral and descriptive. Terms like "acerbe critique" are used, but accurately reflect the content discussed.

2/5

Bias by Omission

The review focuses heavily on the book's content and message, but omits discussion of the graphic novel's artistic style, visual storytelling techniques, and the collaboration between the author and illustrator. This omission limits a full understanding of the work's overall impact and effectiveness.

2/5

False Dichotomy

The review presents a somewhat simplistic dichotomy between the "prométhéenne" vision of infinite growth and the proposed solution of "techno-discernement." It could benefit from acknowledging more nuanced approaches to technological advancement and sustainable development.

Jan 23, 01:10

Schneider Electric Tops Global Sustainability Ranking

Corporate Knights named Schneider Electric the world's most sustainable company in its annual Global 100 index, ranking 8,359 companies with over \$1 billion in revenue based on sustainability and ethical factors; the index, however, underperformed the MSCI ACWI in 2024.

Jan 22, 13:11

WA Government Funds $175,000 Rare Earth Research Project

The WA Government provided $175,000 to RSC Consulting for research into rare earth extraction in the Yilgarn region, involving collaborations with junior mining firms like Terrain Minerals and Dreadnought Resources and Curtin University to establish a new rare earth province and unlock the region's critical minerals wealth for emerging industries.

Jan 21, 01:10

Dutch Agriculture: 50% Ammonia Emission Reduction Possible Through Innovation

A Wageningen University study commissioned by Dutch provinces reveals that agricultural ammonia emissions can be reduced by almost 50 percent within five years using available and upcoming technologies, mainly in dairy farming, potentially enabling all provinces to meet nitrogen targets, though livestock reduction remains necessary.

Jan 20, 04:08

China Discovers Major Rare Earth Deposit in Yunnan

China announced the discovery of a major rare earth deposit in Yunnan province, containing 1.15 million metric tons of potential resources, including over 470,000 tons of critical rare earths vital for electric vehicles and renewable energy, further strengthening its global dominance in this sector.