elpais.com
Illustrated Indian Cuisine: A Culinary Journey Through Recipes and History
The Illustrated Indian Cookbook," by Pankaj Sharma, Alice Charbin, and Sandra Salmandjee, and "Dishoom: From Bombay with Love," by Shamil and Kavi Thakrar and Naved Nasir, offer visually rich explorations of Indian cuisine, tracing its diverse regional styles and historical influences.
- What are the key distinctions between the culinary traditions of North, South, East, and West India, as depicted in "The Illustrated Indian Cookbook"?
- The Illustrated Indian Cookbook" highlights the North's wheat, millet, and maize flatbreads, vegetable curries, and lentil-based sauces (dal); the South's coconut chutneys, vada, papadum, dosas, and idlis; the East's rice-centric dishes, panch phoron spice blend, and fish curry; and the West's nut-based snacks and vegetarian cuisine. Each region showcases unique ingredients and preparation methods.
- What is the significance of the continued use of "Bombay" in culinary literature despite the official name change to "Mumbai", and what broader implications does this have?
- The persistence of "Bombay" in cookbooks reflects a nostalgic connection to the city's colonial past and its vibrant immigrant culture. This use of the older name signifies the rich tapestry of history and cultural fusion embedded in Bombay's culinary heritage, a heritage that transcends the official renaming and resonates with a deeper sense of place and identity for many.
- How do the two cookbooks, "The Illustrated Indian Cookbook" and "Dishoom: From Bombay with Love," approach the representation of Indian culinary history and cultural identity?
- The Illustrated Indian Cookbook" blends historical context with step-by-step recipes and illustrations, showcasing the evolution of Indian cuisine. "Dishoom: From Bombay with Love" focuses on Bombay's (Mumbai's) culinary landscape, narrating its history through recipes reflecting diverse cultural influences and the evolution of the city's food scene, from street food to fine dining.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The article presents a positive and enthusiastic framing of Indian cuisine and culture, focusing on its richness, diversity, and historical significance. The descriptions are consistently evocative and appreciative, potentially overlooking any negative aspects or challenges related to Indian food or culture. The titles of the books mentioned are presented in a way that suggests they are valuable and worthwhile acquisitions.
Language Bias
The language used is largely positive and celebratory, employing words like "visceral," "inspiring," "beautiful," and "joyfully crazy." While this creates an engaging read, it lacks the neutrality expected in objective reporting. For example, instead of 'joyfully crazy', a more neutral term could be 'vibrant and diverse'.
Bias by Omission
The article focuses heavily on the positive aspects of Indian cuisine and culture, potentially omitting discussions of challenges like food insecurity, socioeconomic disparities related to food access, or potentially negative historical aspects of the culinary traditions. The scope of the article might necessitate these omissions, but it's worth considering.
False Dichotomy
The article doesn't present explicit false dichotomies. However, the overwhelmingly positive portrayal of Indian food might implicitly create a false dichotomy by neglecting potential complexities or criticisms.
Sustainable Development Goals
The article focuses on Indian cuisine, highlighting its diversity and richness. Promoting traditional food and recipes can contribute to food security and sustainable food systems by preserving culinary heritage and encouraging the use of local ingredients. The books mentioned showcase a wide variety of recipes, potentially inspiring people to cook more at home and appreciate diverse food sources. This can contribute to healthier diets and reduced food waste.