nrc.nl
Indian Skateboarder Defies Patriarchy, Inspires Change
Asha Gond, a 25-year-old Adivasi woman from Janwaar, India, defied threats of violence to become India's sole female skateboarder at the 2018 World Championships in Nanjing, China, inspiring other girls and challenging patriarchal norms; photographer Chantal Pinzi documented this in her "Shred the Patriarchy" series.
- What is the significance of Asha Gond's achievements in the context of gender inequality in India?
- Asha Gond, an Adivasi woman from Janwaar, India, became the first from her village to obtain a passport and travel abroad, inspiring other girls. She faced threats and abuse for skateboarding, yet persevered, representing India in the 2018 World Skateboarding Championships. Her actions challenge traditional gender roles and inspire hope.
- How does skateboarding serve as a form of resistance against patriarchal norms for women and girls in India?
- Gond's skateboarding journey exemplifies the resilience of women in the face of patriarchal oppression in India. Despite threats of violence, she and other girls use skateboarding as a form of rebellion, defying expectations and societal norms. This resistance is documented by photographer Chantal Pinzi, whose work highlights the power of sport to challenge inequality.
- What are the potential long-term impacts of increased female participation in skateboarding on societal attitudes and gender relations in India?
- The increasing visibility of female skateboarders in India, fueled by the sport's inclusion in the Olympics, is slowly changing perceptions. Gond's establishment of a program with Barefoot Skateboarders, promoting education and development, signifies a broader shift toward female empowerment and challenges the deeply rooted patriarchal structures. This trend, while nascent, offers hope for future progress.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The framing is overwhelmingly positive, focusing on the success stories and empowering aspects of skateboarding for girls. The headline (not provided, but inferred from the content) would likely highlight the positive impact of skateboarding. While the article mentions threats and challenges, the overall narrative emphasizes the triumph over adversity, potentially overshadowing the ongoing struggles faced by many girls in similar situations. The selection and prioritization of information contribute to this positive framing.
Language Bias
The language used is largely positive and empowering, using words like 'strong', 'independent', 'self-reliant' to describe the girls. While these descriptions are accurate, the overall tone is enthusiastic and almost celebratory, which might subtly downplay the ongoing difficulties these girls face. Some words, such as 'gruwelijke bedreigingen' (horrific threats) could be considered loaded; while factually accurate, it dramatically emphasizes the negative and could be softened to 'serious threats'.
Bias by Omission
The article focuses heavily on the positive impacts of skateboarding on girls' empowerment, but it omits potential negative aspects or challenges faced by these girls outside of their skateboarding activities. While the article mentions threats and discrimination, it doesn't delve into the complexities of their daily lives or the broader societal issues they might encounter beyond skateboarding. This omission could create an overly optimistic view of the situation and may neglect crucial details that could affect the reader's understanding of the full context.
False Dichotomy
The article presents a somewhat simplistic dichotomy between traditional patriarchal expectations and the empowerment brought about by skateboarding. While skateboarding offers a path to self-reliance and challenges traditional gender roles, the reality is likely more nuanced. The article doesn't explore potential internal conflicts or complexities within the girls' families and communities regarding their participation in skateboarding.
Gender Bias
The article focuses primarily on the experiences of girls and women, which is appropriate given the subject matter. However, the lack of male perspectives on the issue could be considered a form of gender bias by omission, as it presents a solely female-centric viewpoint and lacks the contrasting perspective of how males might respond to or contribute to the social changes caused by girls' skateboarding. The article could benefit from mentioning how the family members and community members who did not initially support the girls' skateboarding activities might feel about the changes skateboarding has brought about in their community.
Sustainable Development Goals
The article highlights the positive impact of skateboarding on the lives of young women in India, challenging gender norms and promoting empowerment. Asha Gond, the first woman from her village to obtain a passport and travel abroad, serves as an inspiring role model. The initiative also promotes education and development within the community. The photographer's work visually documents the women's resistance against oppression and inequality, directly contributing to raising awareness and challenging gender stereotypes. The inclusion of skateboarding in the Olympics further legitimizes the activity and potentially opens doors to new opportunities for these women.