roma.corriere.it
Italian Judge and Government Clash over Migration Policies
Italian judge Silvia Albano seeks dialogue with the government but insists on judicial independence, leading to conflict over migration policies and the interpretation of European law.
Italian
Italy
PoliticsGovernmentEuropeLawRefugees And MigrationJudiciary
Magistratura DemocraticaEuropean Court Of JusticeItalian Government
Silvia AlbanoCarlo Nordio
- How does Judge Albano characterize her role in the ongoing controversy?
- Albano feels she has become a "lightning rod" in a political controversy that has escalated into intimidation. Nordio, while respecting freedom of speech, defends the government's right to revise laws deemed inefficient.
- What is the upcoming legal challenge concerning the detention of migrants?
- The government's decree-law on "safe countries" is being challenged by judges. A Rome court is expected to rule on the detention of migrants in Albanian containers, potentially leading to further conflict.
- What legal principle does Judge Albano emphasize regarding the interpretation of laws?
- Albano highlights that Italian judges are also European judges, subject to European law. National legislation is subordinate to European law, and judges must refer to the European Court of Justice if they have doubts.
- What is Judge Silvia Albano's stance on the conflict between the judiciary and the government?
- Judge Silvia Albano, president of Magistratura democratica, wants dialogue with the government but won't compromise on principles. She emphasizes the importance of interpreting laws and assessing their compatibility with the constitution.
- What is Justice Minister Carlo Nordio's position on the conflict and the role of the judiciary?
- Minister of Justice Carlo Nordio seeks dialogue with the judiciary, advocating for less political criticism from judges and less political attacks on judges.