faz.net
Keith Jarrett's "Köln Concert": Artistic Rejection and a New Film
Keith Jarrett's 1975 solo piano improvisation, "Köln Concert," recorded in Cologne, Germany, is a landmark jazz album, despite Jarrett's later rejection due to the poor piano and his physical and artistic dissatisfaction; a new film "Köln 75" reinterprets the event.
- Why did Keith Jarrett reject his own "Köln Concert", and what factors influenced his artistic dissatisfaction?
- Jarrett's criticism of the Köln Concert highlights the tension between artistic intent and audience reception. His concerns about the subpar piano and his own physical state during the performance are contrasted by the album's atmospheric density and formal coherence, achieved despite these limitations. The concert's popularity stems from its improvisational nature and delicate balance between simplicity and beauty.
- What makes Keith Jarrett's "Köln Concert" a significant event in jazz history, and what are its immediate artistic and commercial impacts?
- The 1975 Köln Concert by Keith Jarrett, a solo piano improvisation, is considered a landmark recording in jazz history, comparable to Benny Goodman's 1938 Carnegie Hall concert or Miles Davis' Kind of Blue. Jarrett's vehement rejection of the work stems from his dislike of its commercial success and his dissatisfaction with his performance due to the poor piano and his physical condition.
- How does the upcoming film "Köln 75" reinterpret the story of the "Köln Concert", and what implications does this have for the balance between artistic control and public perception?
- The upcoming film "Köln 75" about the Köln Concert raises questions about artistic control and legacy. The filmmakers' exclusion of Jarrett and the ECM team suggests a narrative prioritizing the local organizer's role. This raises concerns about the potential distortion of the event's true story and the imposition of a new myth over the existing one, even without the original music.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The narrative is framed primarily through Jarrett's perspective and his ambivalent feelings toward the "Köln Concert." While acknowledging the concert's significance, the framing emphasizes Jarrett's criticisms and personal struggles, potentially overshadowing other relevant aspects such as the concert's artistic achievements and its cultural impact. The headline (if there were one) would likely emphasize Jarrett's disapproval rather than the concert's artistic merit.
Language Bias
The language used is generally neutral and descriptive. However, phrases like "abgehalfterter Stutzflügel" (decrepit grand piano) and references to Jarrett's "mystical aura" could be considered slightly loaded, as they impart subjective judgments. More neutral phrasing could replace such terms. The overall tone, however, is analytical and seeks to provide balanced perspective.
Bias by Omission
The analysis focuses heavily on Jarrett's personal feelings and opinions about the concert, and the issues surrounding its production. It mentions the involvement of various individuals, but lacks detailed accounts of their roles and perspectives, potentially omitting crucial contextual information about the concert's organization and reception. The article also doesn't explore other interpretations of the concert's significance or its impact beyond Jarrett's personal view.
False Dichotomy
The article presents a somewhat false dichotomy between Jarrett's negative assessment of the concert and its widespread popularity and acclaim. It doesn't fully explore the possibility of simultaneously appreciating the concert's artistic merit and understanding Jarrett's reservations about its production and reception.