sueddeutsche.de
Ken Follett's "Stonehenge": A New Historical Novel
Ken Follett's new historical novel, "Stonehenge - The Cathedral of Time," recounts the construction of Stonehenge 4500 years ago, focusing on the challenges and human drama involved in moving massive stones across the English landscape.
- What is the central theme of Follett's "Stonehenge", and what are its immediate implications for readers?
- The central theme is the human endeavor to construct Stonehenge, highlighting the struggles, collaboration, and ambition of Neolithic people. The implications for readers are an immersive historical experience, exploring themes of faith, community, and human resilience in the face of adversity.
- What are the critiques of Follett's writing style, and how does "Stonehenge" address or deviate from these criticisms?
- Critics often point to Follett's predictable plot structures and stereotypical characters. While "Stonehenge" largely adheres to Follett's established style of short, fast-paced sentences, the focus on the ambitious construction project and the diverse challenges faced by its builders might appeal to even those who find his characters simplistic.
- How does Follett's meticulous research process shape the narrative, and what are the broader implications of his approach?
- Follett's rigorous, year-long research, including consultation with historians, ensures historical accuracy and detail in his narrative. This approach lends credibility to the fictional story, while also offering readers a glimpse into the potential realities of the past, engaging them with a more believable historical reconstruction.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The article presents a balanced view of Ken Follett's work, acknowledging both positive critical reception (bestseller status, clear narrative technique) and negative critiques (predictable plots, bland characters). The author presents both sides without explicitly favoring one, although the positive aspects are perhaps given slightly more weight due to the high sales figures mentioned early on. The headline itself is descriptive rather than opinionated.
Language Bias
The language used is largely neutral and descriptive. Terms like "backsteindicken Historienromane" (brick-thick historical novels) are descriptive and don't carry significant bias. The inclusion of quotes directly from Follett adds objectivity. However, phrases like "einfache Menschen, die Großes leisten" (simple people who achieve great things) might subtly suggest a romanticized view of the characters.
Bias by Omission
The article omits discussion of potential biases present within Follett's portrayal of historical events or the perspectives of marginalized groups within the historical contexts of his novels. While acknowledging various theories surrounding Stonehenge's origins, it doesn't delve into potential critiques or alternative interpretations of those theories. The focus remains largely on Follett's writing style and process.
False Dichotomy
The article presents a false dichotomy by suggesting that critics either praise Follett's clear style or criticize his predictability. The reality is more nuanced; some readers might appreciate both aspects, while others might dislike both. The simplistic portrayal of the critical response is an oversimplification of a more complex reality.
Gender Bias
The article mentions both male and female characters in Follett's novels. However, it doesn't delve into the gender dynamics within the narratives or assess the representation of women in terms of their roles, agency, or character development. More analysis would be needed to fully assess the presence or absence of gender bias.
Sustainable Development Goals
The article highlights the author's meticulous research process for his historical novels, involving consultation with history professors and other experts. This emphasizes the importance of accurate historical knowledge and the role of education in shaping understanding of the past. Although not directly about education, the process reflects the value of rigorous scholarly work and expertise, which are essential components of a quality education system.