cbsnews.com
Kennedy's HHS Nomination: A Q&A on Controversial Health Policies
Analysis of Robert F. Kennedy Jr.'s controversial stances on vaccines, food chemicals, and fluoride, and their potential impact on public health.
English
United States
PoliticsUs PoliticsHealthFood SafetyVaccinesPublic Policy
Department Of Health And Human Services (Hhs)National Institutes Of Health (Nih)Centers For Disease Control And Prevention (Cdc)Food And Drug Administration (Fda)Centers For Medicare And Medicaid Services
Robert F. Kennedy Jr.Donald TrumpDr. Céline GounderSusie Wiles
- What is the role of the Department of Health and Human Services, and how much power does the HHS secretary have over its work?
- The Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) oversees numerous agencies like the NIH, CDC, and FDA, setting policy priorities aligned with the administration's goals. The HHS secretary has significant authority over these agencies and their regulations, influencing policy and public opinion.
- Kennedy has said he wants to leave it up to individuals to decide whether to vaccinate themselves or their children. What impact could that have?
- Allowing individuals to decide on vaccination based on unscientific information is risky, as it relies on emotion and confirmation bias rather than research. This can lead to preventable disease outbreaks and endanger vulnerable populations.
- Kennedy has also said chemicals in food are tied to autism as well as psychotic episodes and depression. What do we know about the connection between food and mental health?
- While a connection between diet and mental health is being researched, no specific diet cures autism or mental health conditions. However, some dietary changes, like limiting ultra-processed foods, may improve symptoms in certain individuals.
- One of Kennedy's most controversial stances is his criticism of vaccines, promoting the idea that they cause autism, among other conditions, and claiming "there's no vaccine that is safe and effective." What is the reality?
- Extensive research disproves the link between vaccines and autism; claims to the contrary are based on retracted studies and professional misconduct. The reality is that while nothing is 100% safe, vaccines significantly outweigh the risks of preventable diseases.
- Kennedy has said one of the Trump administration's first acts will be to work to remove fluoride from drinking water, arguing it's connected to cancer, IQ loss, thyroid disease and other health problems. Why is fluoride in drinking water, and is it safe?
- Fluoride in water helps prevent cavities; its safety depends on dosage. The level in U.S. water is safe, and removing it could increase cavity rates. Public health powers in the U.S. are mainly at the state level, not federal.