genova.repubblica.it
Liguria: High Harassment Rate Despite Crime Reduction
A report reveals that 10.3% of Ligurian women aged 14-70 reported harassment outside work in the past three years, the second highest in Italy, while reported crimes decreased but organized crime increased, and calls to anti-violence hotlines rose significantly.
- How do the trends in reported crime and organized crime in Liguria relate to changes in citizens' perceptions of safety?
- Liguria's high harassment rate reflects a broader societal issue, despite improvements in perceived safety. While reported crimes decreased 5.9% since 2018, organized crime-related offenses increased 16.6% in 2023, reaching 785 per 100,000 inhabitants. This contrasts with a decrease in the percentage of citizens whose lives are significantly affected by crime, from 31.6% in 2015-16 to 22.7% in 2024.
- What are the immediate implications of Liguria's high rate of reported harassment and increased calls to anti-violence hotlines?
- In Liguria, 10.3% of women aged 14-70 reported experiencing harassment outside of work, the second highest rate in Italy. Calls to the 1522 anti-violence hotline increased by 67.1% (717 calls) and victim calls rose by 78.8% (279 calls) in the first three quarters of 2024 compared to 2023. However, women supported by anti-violence centers decreased from 1,014 to 708.
- What underlying issues could explain the discrepancy between the increased calls to anti-violence hotlines and the decrease in women taken into care by anti-violence centers in Liguria?
- The disparity between increased hotline calls and decreased center support suggests challenges in accessing aid. The rise in organized crime, despite improvements in perceived safety and reported crime, underscores the need for a comprehensive approach addressing both direct victim support and systematic crime reduction. Further investigation into the effectiveness of current interventions is necessary.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The report's framing emphasizes the negative aspects of crime and violence in Liguria. While it includes some positive data (e.g., decrease in total crimes, improved perceived safety), the focus is heavily on the increase in domestic violence, murders, and organized crime. This creates a somewhat alarmist tone, potentially overlooking positive progress or successes in specific areas. The headline (if one existed) would likely highlight the alarming statistics over the positive trends, further reinforcing the negative framing.
Language Bias
The language used tends to be alarmist. Phrases like "second highest value in Italy," "in crescita," and "in aumento" repeatedly emphasize negative trends. While accurate, this choice of words contributes to an overall tone that could be considered unnecessarily negative. More neutral phrasing would include simply stating the numerical changes, and contextually discussing the implications of increase or decreases without resorting to immediately negative language.
Bias by Omission
The report focuses heavily on crime statistics but lacks crucial context. For instance, while it mentions an increase in calls to the 1522 anti-violence hotline, it doesn't discuss the reasons for this increase. Are there more effective outreach programs? Increased awareness? Or a genuine surge in violence? Similarly, the decrease in women taken in by anti-violence centers isn't explained. This omission prevents a full understanding of the situation. The report also omits details on the types of harassment experienced by women, the demographics of offenders, and details on support services offered beyond the 1522 hotline and anti-violence centers. The lack of information on prevention efforts also limits the report's overall value.
False Dichotomy
The report presents a somewhat simplistic view of safety by contrasting crime statistics with perceived safety. It doesn't explore the complexities of how these concepts interact. For example, a decrease in reported crime doesn't necessarily mean an increase in safety, as underreporting is a common issue, particularly in cases of domestic violence. The report also implies a direct correlation between a decrease in reported crimes and an improvement in perceived safety, which is an oversimplification.
Gender Bias
The report disproportionately focuses on violence against women, which is important, but it does so while neglecting the experiences of male victims. This could lead to a skewed perception of violence and the need for support services. Furthermore, while the report cites statistics on women experiencing harassment, it lacks information on the perpetrators, their demographics, or the context of the harassment. Providing this data would lead to a more balanced and effective understanding of the issue.
Sustainable Development Goals
The report highlights that 10.3% of women in Liguria aged 14-70 have experienced harassment outside of work, the second highest rate in Italy. This indicates a significant issue with gender-based violence and a failure to ensure women