zeit.de
Lombok's Marina Bay City: A Controversial Tourism Development
A $1 billion Marina Bay City project is underway on Lombok, Indonesia, promising economic benefits but sparking concerns about environmental damage and displacement mirroring issues seen in Bali and other tourist hotspots.
- What are the immediate economic impacts of the Marina Bay City project on Lombok?
- The project promises to create jobs in construction and long-term positions in tourism. Local residents hope to benefit from increased employment and economic activity, although concerns exist that the benefits may not reach all segments of the community.
- How does the Marina Bay City project compare to other large-scale developments in popular tourist destinations?
- Similar controversies surround large-scale developments in places like Mallorca and the Canary Islands, where large hotel chains displace smaller businesses, and in Bali, which faces overtourism. The project mirrors conflicts between local communities and large-scale investors, raising concerns about potential displacement and environmental impact.
- What are the potential long-term environmental and social consequences of the Marina Bay City project and similar developments on Lombok and other Indonesian islands?
- Critics warn of potential environmental damage, displacement of local communities, and the loss of Lombok's unique character. Concerns exist that the project could contribute to overtourism, repeating the negative impacts seen in Bali and potentially leading to the degradation of other Indonesian islands unless sustainable practices are prioritized.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The article presents a balanced view of the Marina Bay City project in Lombok, showcasing both the optimism of locals hoping for economic benefits and the concerns of critics worried about environmental damage and displacement. The framing is largely neutral, although the use of phrases like "David against Goliath" subtly favors the perspective of local residents. The inclusion of counterarguments from critics and parallels to other tourism-heavy areas like Mallorca and the Canary Islands prevents the article from overly promoting the project.
Language Bias
The language used is mostly neutral and descriptive. While terms like "idyllic" and "unberührt" (untouched) describe Buwun Mas positively, these are balanced by descriptions of potential negative consequences like "Schandfleck" (blot) used in a critical quote. There is no significant use of loaded language.
Bias by Omission
While the article provides a comprehensive overview, potential omissions include a detailed analysis of the environmental impact assessment for Marina Bay City, specific details on the job creation promises, and a deeper exploration of the government's role in regulating the project. However, given the scope of the article, these omissions are likely due to practical constraints rather than intentional bias.
Sustainable Development Goals
The development of Marina Bay City on Lombok Island, while promising economic benefits, raises concerns about unsustainable urban development and its potential negative impacts on the environment and local communities. The article highlights concerns about the displacement of local businesses, potential environmental damage, and the overall loss of Lombok's unique character, mirroring issues seen in other tourist destinations. The comparison to Bali and Mykonos underscores the potential for unsustainable tourism to negatively impact a community's quality of life and environment. The proposed mega-resort on Padar Island further exemplifies this risk, threatening the Komodo dragon habitat.