lexpress.fr
Maman déchire": A Family's Struggle with Intergenerational Trauma
Ten years after "Pauline s'arrache," Emilie Brisavoine's "Maman déchire" documents her family's ongoing struggles, revealing intergenerational trauma and the director's attempts at healing through therapy and confronting her family.
- What are the primary societal impacts revealed by the film's depiction of intergenerational trauma and family dysfunction?
- Emilie Brisavoine's "Maman déchire" revisits her family ten years after "Pauline s'arrache," offering a raw portrayal of dysfunction. The film uses unhidden cameras to document ongoing family conflicts and the director's attempts at reconciliation, revealing complex intergenerational trauma.
- How does the film's use of unhidden cameras shape its portrayal of family dynamics and the director's emotional involvement?
- The film's unflinching depiction of family conflict connects to broader themes of intergenerational trauma and the lasting impact of dysfunctional family dynamics. Specific examples include the parents' chaotic past and the director's own struggles to process the situation.
- What are the lasting effects of the family dynamic portrayed in the film, and what broader societal commentary can be derived?
- Maman déchire" suggests that unresolved family trauma can be passed down across generations, impacting the mental health and well-being of children. The director's journey highlights the difficulty of healing from such trauma, even with professional help.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The review frames the films as 'chef-d'oeuvres,' using overwhelmingly positive and hyperbolic language. The focus on the chaotic family dynamics and the filmmaker's personal journey overshadows any potential criticisms or nuanced perspectives on the films' content or impact. The emphasis on the filmmaker's courage and financial struggles evokes sympathy and admiration, potentially influencing the reader's perception of the films' quality.
Language Bias
The review employs highly charged and subjective language ('infamante étiquette,' 'cassos,' 'usine à se cracher à la gueule,' 'enfer'), hyperbolic expressions ('pure magie, drolatique de pathétique'), and strong opinions ('honte à vous, public chéri!') that influence reader interpretation. More neutral language could improve objectivity. For example, instead of 'cassos,' the review could describe the family's interpersonal conflicts more neutrally.
Bias by Omission
The review focuses heavily on the filmmaker's family dynamics and personal struggles, potentially omitting broader societal contexts or similar family situations. While the review acknowledges the filmmaker's financial struggles, it doesn't explore potential external factors influencing the family's dysfunction, such as socioeconomic pressures or access to mental healthcare.
False Dichotomy
The review presents a false dichotomy by categorizing films into either 'WTF' or 'CQCD,' neglecting the diversity of filmmaking styles and genres. It also implies that only those who appreciated "Pauline s'arrache" will appreciate "Maman déchire," overlooking potential appreciation from viewers with different tastes.
Gender Bias
While the review doesn't explicitly promote gender stereotypes, it predominantly focuses on the female characters' physical appearances and emotional struggles, potentially overlooking other aspects of their lives or personalities. The mother's transformation from 'very pretty' to 'not at all' is highlighted, suggesting an association of attractiveness with youth and societal standards of beauty.
Sustainable Development Goals
The film depicts a family dynamic where parents are struggling, and the educational prospects of their children, especially Pauline, are negatively affected by the chaotic environment. The lack of stability and consistent parental support hinders the children's ability to thrive academically and emotionally. The quote "Ceux qui aiment les enfants n'en font pas" highlights the dysfunctional family dynamic and its impact on the children's well-being, indirectly affecting their education.