nbcnews.com
New Orleans Repatriates Remains of 19 African Americans Sent to Germany for Racist Research
The remains of 19 African Americans, sent to Germany for racist research in the 19th century, were returned to New Orleans on Saturday and given a multifaith memorial service and burial at the Hurricane Katrina Memorial, highlighting the ongoing reckoning with historical injustices.
- What are the immediate implications of the return and reburial of the 19 African Americans' remains for New Orleans and the broader fight against systemic racism?
- Nineteen African American individuals' remains, sent to Germany for racist research in the 19th century, were returned to New Orleans and given a multifaith memorial service and burial. The remains, skulls from individuals who died at Charity Hospital between 1871 and 1872, were repatriated by the University of Leipzig after Dillard University spearheaded the effort. This event highlights the ongoing reckoning with historical injustices and the importance of respecting the deceased.
- What future research is needed to fully understand the historical context surrounding the individuals whose remains were returned, and what steps should be taken to prevent similar abuses in the future?
- This event could spur further investigation into similar cases of unethical research practices involving the exploitation of Black bodies. Future efforts might focus on identifying descendants of the 19 individuals and expanding research on the history of Charity Hospital and its role during the period of white supremacist oppression in New Orleans. This may also lead to renewed dialogue about the ethics of scientific research and the protection of vulnerable populations.
- How did the collaboration between Dillard University and the University of Leipzig contribute to the repatriation of the remains, and what does this partnership signify about international efforts to address historical injustices?
- The repatriation of the remains connects to a broader pattern of addressing historical injustices and the legacy of racism in scientific research. The German university's initiative to return the remains demonstrates a commitment to rectifying past wrongs. This action underscores the importance of acknowledging and rectifying the exploitation of marginalized communities in the name of science.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The framing of the article centers on the return and respectful reburial of the remains, highlighting the dignity afforded to those who were previously subjected to disrespectful treatment. This positive framing is appropriate given the context of the story. The headline and introductory paragraphs effectively set this tone.
Language Bias
The language used is largely neutral and respectful, avoiding loaded terms. The use of words like "desecration" accurately reflects the gravity of the situation without being overly inflammatory. Words like "dignity" and "respectful" appropriately convey the sentiment of the event.
Bias by Omission
The article could benefit from including information about the specific research conducted by the German researcher beyond phrenology. While phrenology is mentioned, details about the nature and extent of the research on these remains would enrich the reader's understanding of the historical context. Additionally, the article omits any mention of potential responses from the descendants of the 19 individuals, if any have been identified or contacted. This could be a significant aspect of the story.
Sustainable Development Goals
The repatriation and reburial of the remains of 19 African Americans whose skulls were used for racist research in Germany directly addresses the issue of historical injustices against marginalized groups, particularly Black people. The act acknowledges past harms and works towards restorative justice, contributing to gender equality by recognizing the humanity and dignity of individuals previously subjected to racist practices. The event also highlights the ongoing need to confront systemic racism and discrimination.