rfi.fr
Notre-Dame's Controversial Contemporary Stained-Glass Windows
A debate rages over replacing restored medieval stained-glass windows at Notre-Dame with contemporary works, causing a clash between historical preservation and modern artistic expression.
French
France
FranceControversyArtRestorationNotre-DameStained Glass
La Tribune De L'artUnescoCommission Nationale Du Patrimoine Et De L'architectureSite Et Monuments
Eugène Viollet-Le-DucEmmanuel MacronDidier RyknerMonseigneur UlrichCamille Pascal
- What is the estimated cost and what is the argument for its justification?
- The project's cost is estimated in the millions of euros, yet supporters see it as a worthwhile investment if it results in significant contemporary art pieces. The potential for future acclaim adds to its perceived value.
- Who opposes the replacement of the original stained-glass windows and why?
- Historian Didier Rykner strongly opposes the replacement, launching a petition with over 200,000 signatures to preserve the original windows. He argues against removing historically significant, classified monuments, regardless of the quality of potential replacements.
- What arguments support the inclusion of contemporary stained-glass windows?
- Supporters of the contemporary art project argue that it will add a modern element to the cathedral's history, reflecting the 21st century. They cite examples of renowned contemporary artists creating meaningful stained-glass works for other structures as evidence of the project's merit.
- What is the main point of contention regarding Notre-Dame Cathedral's restoration?
- The controversy surrounds the replacement of existing stained-glass windows at Notre-Dame Cathedral with contemporary works. The original windows, designed by Eugène Viollet-le-Duc, survived the 2019 fire and have been restored, yet the decision to replace them with modern pieces has sparked a debate.
- What is the official stance of relevant organizations regarding the installation of new windows?
- The Commission nationale du patrimoine et de l'architecture has opposed the installation of new windows and some organizations plan legal action. This highlights the deep divisions within the art and heritage communities regarding the project.