npr.org
Oldest Known Cookbook by Black American Woman Republished
Malinda Russell's 1866 cookbook, "A Domestic Cookbook," recently republished, is the oldest known by a Black American woman; it features recipes for sweets, savory dishes, and remedies, reflecting her life as a widowed entrepreneur who overcame robberies to support herself and her disabled son.
- How does Russell's life story and entrepreneurial endeavors inform the content and context of her cookbook?
- Russell's cookbook challenges the previously held belief that Abby Fisher's 1881 cookbook was the oldest. The discovery and republication highlight the overlooked contributions of Black women to American culinary history and entrepreneurship during a challenging post-Civil War era. The book's contents reflect Russell's resourcefulness and business acumen, including recipes and remedies.
- What is the significance of Malinda Russell's "A Domestic Cookbook" being republished, and what does it reveal about American culinary history?
- A newly published edition of Malinda Russell's "A Domestic Cookbook," written in 1866, is the oldest known cookbook by a Black American woman. Russell, a widowed single mother with a disabled child, self-published the book partly to recoup losses from robberies, showcasing her resilience and entrepreneurial spirit. The cookbook contains recipes for sweets, savory dishes, and even remedies.
- What challenges do historians face in interpreting and recreating recipes from historical cookbooks like Russell's, and what further research could illuminate this aspect of American history?
- The rediscovery and republication of Russell's cookbook signal a growing interest in recovering and celebrating the contributions of marginalized groups to American history. The lack of precise measurements in her recipes reflects the culinary practices of the time and provides a unique window into 19th-century American life. Future research could focus on recovering other lost works by Black women.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The article frames Malinda Russell's story as one of resilience and entrepreneurial spirit, emphasizing her hardships and perseverance. While this is a valid aspect of her life, the framing could be broadened to avoid focusing primarily on her struggles. The headline and introduction strongly emphasize her hardships and the discovery of her book, rather than providing a balanced overview of her life and the significance of her cookbook within the broader context of culinary history.
Language Bias
The language used is generally neutral, but phrases like "old-fashioned desserts" and "still sound delicious" carry a subjective tone. While intended to be evocative, such language could subtly influence reader perception and should be replaced with more objective descriptions. For example, instead of "old-fashioned desserts," a more neutral term would be "traditional desserts from the era.
Bias by Omission
The article focuses heavily on Malinda Russell and her cookbook, but omits discussion of other contemporary cookbooks by Black women or the broader socio-economic context surrounding her life and work. While acknowledging space constraints, the lack of comparative analysis limits the reader's understanding of Russell's place within a larger culinary and social landscape. For example, mentioning other Black female authors and comparing their experiences and the style of their cookbooks would enrich the narrative.
False Dichotomy
The article presents a false dichotomy by initially framing Russell's cookbook as the oldest by a Black American woman, only later acknowledging earlier works by Black men. While clarifying this, the narrative structure still emphasizes Russell's achievement as a primary focus, inadvertently downplaying the contributions of these earlier authors and creating a simplified narrative of culinary history.
Gender Bias
The article focuses on personal details about Russell's life, such as her widowhood and handicapped child. While relevant to her story, the emphasis on these details might perpetuate stereotypes of Black women as caregivers. There is no similar level of detail provided about the lives of the male authors mentioned. The focus should be shifted to her culinary achievements and impact on culinary history.
Sustainable Development Goals
Malinda Russell's story highlights resilience and entrepreneurship in overcoming economic hardship. Her cookbook, published to recover from financial losses after robberies, showcases her resourcefulness and drive to build a better life for herself and her son. This aligns with SDG 1 (No Poverty) which aims to end poverty in all its forms everywhere.