english.elpais.com
Post-Apocalyptic Musical "The End" Explores Climate Change Denial
The End," a post-apocalyptic musical by Joshua Oppenheimer, depicts a dysfunctional family's survival in a bunker decades after climate change, using musical numbers to express their denial and despair.
- What are the broader cultural factors contributing to the rise of darker, more unconventional musicals in recent years?
- This trend of darker musicals reflects a shift away from traditionally cheerful narratives. Films like "Carmen," "Cyrano," and "Polvo serán" demonstrate a growing acceptance of using music to explore complex themes of immigration, mortality, and societal issues, challenging the genre's conventional optimism.
- How does "The End's" use of musical numbers challenge conventional notions of the musical genre and its relationship to narrative?
- The film "The End" uses musical numbers to portray a post-apocalyptic family's coping mechanisms in a bunker decades after climate change ravaged Earth. The musical style contrasts sharply with the bleak setting, highlighting the characters' denial and desperate attempts to maintain normalcy.
- What are the potential long-term implications of using musical forms to confront difficult social and environmental issues, as seen in "The End" and similar films?
- The film's use of music to mask harsh realities foreshadows a potential future where escapism through art becomes a prevalent coping mechanism in the face of climate-related challenges. This reflects a growing trend in media of confronting complex issues through unconventional genres.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The article frames the discussion around the rise of "darker" musicals as a significant shift in the genre, emphasizing the unconventional choices of directors like Oppenheimer and Von Trier. The selection of examples and the emphasis on challenging conventions might give the impression that this is a dominant trend, overshadowing the continued popularity and production of more traditional musicals. The headline itself, focusing on the end of the world and the use of song as a coping mechanism, sets a specific tone.
Language Bias
The article uses loaded language like "deranged family", "mournful", "melancholic", "controversial", and "depressive clan" to describe certain films and characters, potentially influencing the reader's perception before they've experienced the works themselves. The use of words like "gambling" and "darkest side" also adds a dramatic, perhaps sensationalized, tone to the analysis. More neutral alternatives could have been used in many instances.
Bias by Omission
The article focuses heavily on auteur-driven musicals that challenge conventions, potentially overlooking the continued success of traditional musicals. While mentioning examples like "The Greatest Showman", "Wicked", and "Wonka", it doesn't delve into their specific characteristics or box office success in detail, offering only a brief comparison. This omission could leave the reader with an incomplete picture of the current musical landscape and the audience's preferences.
False Dichotomy
The article presents a somewhat false dichotomy between traditional, upbeat musicals and darker, auteur-driven musicals. It implies that musicals must choose between adhering to the 'happily ever after' trope or exploring grim realities, neglecting the potential for nuanced storytelling that blends both elements. Many musicals blend light and dark themes effectively; this oversimplification risks misrepresenting the range within the genre.
Gender Bias
The article features several male directors and filmmakers, while female representation is limited. Although Lady Gaga is mentioned, her contribution is mainly focused on her statement about the film, not her role in shaping its narrative. This imbalance might unintentionally reinforce the existing gender dynamics in the film industry and undervalue the contributions of female artists in this specific genre.
Sustainable Development Goals
The movie depicts a post-apocalyptic world ravaged by climate change, highlighting the devastating consequences of inaction and the urgent need for mitigation and adaptation strategies. The setting itself serves as a stark warning about the potential future impacts of climate change.