zeit.de
Post-War German Intellectuals: Gehlen, Adorno, and the Moral Reckoning
Thomas Wagner's "Adventures of Modernity" examines the post-1945 German intellectual scene through the lives and ideas of sociologist Arnold Gehlen, a former Nazi, and Theodor W. Adorno, a Jewish emigrant, highlighting their surprising collaboration and the complexities of post-war German society.
- What factors contributed to the surprising collaboration and public debates between Gehlen and Adorno, despite their vastly different backgrounds and ideologies?
- The book "Adventures of Modernity" explores the post-war intellectual landscape in Germany, focusing on the contrasting lives and theories of Arnold Gehlen, a former Nazi who became a prominent sociologist, and Theodor Adorno, a Jewish emigrant who returned to Germany after the war. Their unlikely friendship and public debates highlight the complex moral ambiguities of post-war German society.
- How did the contrasting experiences and postwar actions of figures like Arnold Gehlen and Theodor Adorno shape the intellectual and moral landscape of post-war Germany?
- After surviving a Russian attack in Silesia near the end of WWII, Lieutenant Arnold Gehlen, upon a suggestion to desert, threatened to shoot any soldier who made a move to leave. This act highlights the unwavering loyalty some German soldiers held to their institutions, even in the face of collapse. Three years later, Max Horkheimer described the unsettling normalcy of Frankfurt University faculty, seemingly unaffected by the war's atrocities.
- To what extent does the book's analysis of the relationship between Gehlen and Adorno offer insights into the ongoing challenges of confronting the past and navigating ideological divisions in contemporary German society?
- The contrasting paths of Gehlen and Adorno illustrate the challenges of reconciliation and the persistence of ideological divisions in post-war Germany. Gehlen's influence on the New Right, despite his past, and Adorno's unwavering commitment to humanist ideals highlight the enduring tensions between conservatism and progressivism in German intellectual life. The book suggests these tensions remain relevant today.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The framing emphasizes the intriguing contrast between Gehlen and Adorno, highlighting their unlikely friendship and intellectual debates. While this approach is engaging, it might overshadow other important aspects of postwar German intellectual history. The title itself, "Adventures of Modernity," while evocative, potentially oversells the book's scope by focusing on these two figures rather than the broader context.
Language Bias
The author employs strong, potentially loaded language in describing Gehlen ('elite Nazi,' 'Lump'), and Adorno's reaction to others. While this adds to the narrative's drama, it could be interpreted as biased, and using more neutral terms might provide a more balanced presentation. For example, instead of 'elite Nazi,' 'prominent member of the Nazi party' could be used.
Bias by Omission
The article focuses heavily on Gehlen and Adorno, potentially omitting other relevant figures or perspectives within German sociology and intellectual life post-WWII. The limited scope, while understandable given the book's focus, may lead to an incomplete picture of the broader intellectual landscape.
False Dichotomy
The narrative sometimes presents a false dichotomy between Gehlen's conservative views and Adorno's more critical stance, oversimplifying the complexities of their intellectual exchange and the diverse opinions within postwar German society.
Gender Bias
The article's focus is primarily on male figures, with limited attention paid to the contributions of women in German sociology during this period. The mention of Elisabeth Noelle-Neumann provides a partial exception but the overall representation remains unbalanced.
Sustainable Development Goals
The article explores the post-World War II German intellectual landscape, examining the reconciliation and collaboration between individuals with vastly different pasts (Nazi collaborators and Jewish emigrants). This reflects on the challenges of establishing peace, justice, and strong institutions after a period of extreme conflict and societal upheaval. The contrasting views and actions of individuals like Arnold Gehlen and Theodor Adorno highlight the complexities of navigating moral ambiguities and rebuilding societal structures based on justice and accountability. The discussion of Gehlen's past and his later interactions with Adorno illustrates the difficulties and nuances of reconciliation in a society grappling with its past.