repubblica.it
Premiolino Awards Highlight Threats to Journalism
The 65th Premiolino journalism prize, sponsored by Pirelli, was awarded to six Italian journalists for their work, highlighting the dangers faced by journalists globally, especially in Ukraine and Gaza, where record numbers were killed in 2024; Italy's press freedom ranking also dropped.
- What are the key findings of this year's Premiolino awards, and what do they signify about the state of journalism in Italy and globally?
- The 65th Premiolino prize, Italy's most prestigious journalism award, was given to six journalists: Luigi Manconi (Repubblica), Paolo Giordano (Corriere della Sera), Anna Zafesova (La Stampa), Siegmund Ginzberg (Il Foglio), Thomas Mackinson (Il Fatto Quotidiano), and Sabrina Giannini (Rai 3). The jury highlighted their narrative quality, professional rigor, and civic commitment. A special mention honored Viktorija Roš?yna, a Ukrainian journalist killed for her reporting.
- What are the long-term implications of the trends highlighted by the Premiolino awards regarding press freedom, disinformation, and the role of journalism in society?
- The Premiolino awards' focus on quality journalism amid rising threats to press freedom signals a growing concern about the spread of misinformation and the decline in media credibility. The recognition of Viktorija Roš?yna's sacrifice highlights the vital role of investigative journalism, suggesting a need for greater international support for journalists operating in dangerous environments. Pirelli's sponsorship emphasizes the need for investment in education and training to combat misinformation and promote media literacy.
- How did the increased threats against journalists, particularly in conflict zones and due to political pressures in Italy, affect the selection criteria for the Premiolino awards this year?
- This year's Premiolino awards emphasized the dangers faced by journalists, particularly in conflict zones like Ukraine and Gaza, where a record number of journalists were killed in 2024. The Italian press freedom ranking dropped from 46th to 49th due to organized crime and political interference, underscoring the importance of quality journalism in combating disinformation. The awards aimed to recognize work that fosters informed public opinion.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The article frames the Premiolino awards positively, highlighting the importance of quality journalism in a challenging environment. The emphasis on the difficult circumstances faced by journalists, especially the tragic death of Viktorija Roš?yna, strengthens this positive framing of the awards. The inclusion of quotes from the jury president and Pirelli executive further reinforces the celebratory tone. However, this framing might unintentionally downplay any criticism of the Italian journalistic landscape.
Language Bias
The language used is largely neutral and factual when describing the awards and winners. However, terms such as "barbaramente torturata" (barbarously tortured) are emotionally charged, reflecting the gravity of the situation but potentially impacting the article's overall objectivity. While appropriate in context, the use of such strong language might subtly influence reader perception. A more neutral phrasing might be considered, although the emotional weight should also be respected.
Bias by Omission
The article focuses on the Premiolino awards and mentions the difficult context for journalists in 2024, particularly in Ukraine and Gaza. However, it omits specific examples of the awarded works beyond a general description of their quality and the journalists' commitment. This omission prevents a full understanding of the basis for the awards and the types of journalism being recognized. While space constraints might explain some omissions, providing brief summaries of the winning works would significantly improve the article.
Gender Bias
The article mentions both male and female winners. While no overt gender bias is apparent in the descriptions of their achievements, a deeper analysis examining the types of journalism awarded and the language used to describe each journalist would be needed to determine whether subtle biases exist.
Sustainable Development Goals
The Pirelli Prize for Schools 2025 highlights the importance of investing in education and continuous learning to foster critical thinking and understanding of evolving realities. This aligns with SDG 4 (Quality Education) by emphasizing the need for quality information and media literacy to combat misinformation and promote informed decision-making.