kathimerini.gr
Previously Unknown Philodemus Papyrus Found in Herculaneum
X-ray technology revealed an unknown work by the Epicurean philosopher Philodemus, part of his "On Evil" series, within the Herculaneum papyrus PHerc.172, a discovery significant for understanding Epicurean ethics and ancient literature.
- What methods were used to uncover the contents of the papyrus PHerc.172 and what challenges were involved in its analysis?
- This discovery is significant because it adds to our understanding of Philodemus's writings and Epicurean ethics. The papyrus's identification was facilitated by existing knowledge about Philodemus's life and writings, including mentions by Cicero and his role as Virgil's teacher. The "On Evil" series was already known, with other books discovered in Herculaneum.
- What is the significance of the newly discovered Philodemus papyrus found in Herculaneum and how does it impact our understanding of ancient philosophy?
- A previously unknown work by the Epicurean philosopher Philodemus has been discovered within the charred papyrus PHerc.172 from Herculaneum, using X-ray technology to scan its contents without physically unrolling it. The text, dating back to the 1st century BC, is part of Philodemus's multi-volume work "On Evil," found in a Roman villa buried by Vesuvius's eruption nearly 2000 years ago.
- What potential future research directions are suggested by this discovery and what further insights might they offer into the writings of Philodemus and Epicurean thought?
- Future research will continue to improve the algorithm for detecting ink and decipher more of the text. This discovery highlights the potential of non-invasive imaging techniques in the study of ancient texts and promises further insights into the philosophical and literary landscape of the Roman world. The ongoing research will clarify additional details and meanings from the papyrus.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The narrative frames the discovery as overwhelmingly positive, emphasizing the technological achievement and the importance of the find for understanding Epicurean ethics. This positive framing is evident in the headline (if one existed) and the overall tone. While justifiable given the nature of the discovery, this focus might overshadow potential challenges or limitations in interpreting the newly discovered text.
Language Bias
The language used is largely neutral and academic. However, phrases such as "overwhelmingly important" could be considered slightly loaded. More neutral alternatives, such as "significant" or "important for understanding," might improve objectivity. The use of "excitement" in describing researcher reaction could be interpreted as subjective.
Bias by Omission
The article focuses primarily on the discovery and analysis of the papyrus, providing details about the methods used and the researchers involved. However, it omits discussion of potential alternative interpretations of the text or differing scholarly opinions on the significance of Philodemus's work. While this omission may be due to space constraints and the focus on the novelty of the discovery, it could limit the reader's ability to fully grasp the broader scholarly context surrounding Philodemus's philosophy.
Gender Bias
The article focuses on the academic achievements of Dr. Michael McOscar, a male researcher, without mentioning the gender of other researchers involved. While this might not be indicative of bias, more balanced representation of research team members would be beneficial. No gendered language or stereotypes are present.
Sustainable Development Goals
The discovery and analysis of the ancient text contributes to our understanding of philosophy and ethics in antiquity, enriching educational resources and historical knowledge. The use of X-ray technology in the project also showcases advancements in technology applied to historical research, which can be used as an educational example.