elmundo.es
Putin's War: A Reflection of Soviet Trauma and Historical Revisionism
The 1957 Soviet film "When the Storks Fly" showcased the emotional aftermath of World War II, contrasting victory celebrations with personal loss, a theme mirrored in Putin's current Ukraine conflict, interpreted by some as an attempt to 'correct' Russia's perceived historical humiliations.
- What are the key historical and political factors contributing to the Russian perspective on the wars in World War II and Ukraine, and how do these narratives differ?
- Putin's current war in Ukraine is interpreted by some as an attempt to 'correct' history and rewrite Russia's past humiliation after the fall of the Berlin Wall. This perspective connects Putin's actions to a deep-seated Russian dissatisfaction with the post-Soviet present, fueled by a desire to restore Russia's image as a great power. The appropriation of the narrative surrounding World War II—referred to as the Great Patriotic War in Russia—further illustrates this point.
- How does the Soviet film "When the Storks Fly" reflect the complex emotional landscape of post-World War II Russia, and how does this relate to Putin's current actions in Ukraine?
- The Soviet film "When the Storks Fly," released in 1957, depicted the emotional toll of World War II on Soviet citizens, contrasting joyful victory celebrations with the quiet grief of those who lost loved ones. This film, viewed by Vladimir Putin as a child, shaped his understanding of the war's impact. The film's message of avoiding future conflict is contrasted with Putin's current actions.
- What are the potential long-term consequences of Putin's manipulation of historical narratives to justify his actions in Ukraine, and how might this affect Russia's future relationship with the West?
- The contrasting narratives surrounding World War II and the current war in Ukraine highlight a complex interplay of historical memory and political manipulation in Russia. Putin's regime has leveraged the national unity forged during World War II to bolster support for the current conflict, despite the significant differences between the two wars. This strategy, however, may be reaching its limits as societal resignation surpasses any potential enthusiasm for the conflict.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The framing consistently portrays Putin's actions as a response to historical grievances and Western aggression, potentially downplaying Russia's own agency in escalating the conflict. The title "LA GUERRA FELIZ" (The Happy War) is particularly jarring and sets a tone that contrasts sharply with the suffering caused by the war. The use of quotes from Putin's regime and those sympathetic to it shape the narrative.
Language Bias
The article uses strong, evocative language to describe Putin's actions ("gran destructor," "guerra de 'historia alternativa'"). While effective in conveying the author's perspective, this language lacks the neutrality expected in objective reporting. The term "LA GUERRA FELIZ" is a particularly charged phrase that influences the reader's perception.
Bias by Omission
The article omits discussion of potential dissenting voices within Russia regarding the war in Ukraine. While acknowledging the broad support for the war stemming from the manipulation of historical narratives, it doesn't delve into the existence or extent of opposition. This omission limits a complete understanding of the societal response to the conflict.
False Dichotomy
The article presents a simplified view of the relationship between Russia's past and present conflicts, particularly by framing the current war as a continuation of past struggles against the West. This oversimplifies the complexities of geopolitical relations and ignores alternative interpretations of historical events.
Gender Bias
The analysis focuses primarily on the actions and perspectives of male figures (Putin, soldiers, historians). While Veronika's story is included, it serves primarily to illustrate the human cost of war rather than offering a balanced representation of female experiences or perspectives during the conflict.
Sustainable Development Goals
The article details the ongoing war in Ukraine, initiated by Russia, which constitutes a grave violation of international peace and security and undermines the rule of law. The conflict has led to immense suffering, displacement, and loss of life, directly contradicting the goals of maintaining international peace and justice. Putin's justification of the war as a means to "correct" history and restore Russia's perceived influence further highlights a disregard for established international norms and institutions.