dw.com
Querino's 1918 Essay Challenges Brazil's 'Whitening' Policies
Manuel Querino's 1918 essay, "O colono preto como fator da civilização brasileira," countered Brazil's "whitening" policies by highlighting Black Brazilians' essential role in the nation's economic development, a perspective that remains relevant in light of recent racist incidents.
- What was the central argument of Manuel Querino's 1918 essay, and how did it challenge the prevailing social and political context of Brazil at the time?
- In 1918, Manuel Querino, a Black Brazilian intellectual, published "O colono preto como fator da civilização brasileira," arguing that enslaved and free Black Brazilians were the foundational workers of the nation, a stark contrast to the prevailing narrative of the time. His essay highlighted the significant contributions of African populations to Brazil's development, directly challenging the government's concurrent "whitening" policies.
- How did the Brazilian government's "whitening" policies of the early 20th century affect the perception and treatment of Black workers, and what role did immigration play in this?
- Querino's work countered Brazil's early 20th-century "whitening" policies, which promoted European immigration and marginalized Black contributions to the nation's economy and culture. His historical analysis directly challenged the prevailing ideology that minimized the labor of Black Brazilians, emphasizing their crucial role in building the country's material wealth.
- What are the lasting implications of Querino's work, considering recent events such as the racist incident involving a Black child and the ongoing struggle for racial and economic justice in Brazil?
- Querino's essay foreshadowed ongoing debates about racial justice and economic equality in Brazil. The recent incident of a Black child being called "CLT" (Consolidation of Labor Laws) in a derogatory manner highlights the persistence of systemic racism within the Brazilian labor system, demonstrating that the fight for labor rights for Black Brazilians continues. This points to the need for continued systemic change to address historical inequities.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The article is framed to highlight the often-overlooked contributions of Black workers to Brazilian history and the ongoing struggle for racial equality in the workplace. The framing is positive and aims to counter historical narratives that minimize or ignore the role of Black Brazilians in building the nation. The use of the anecdote about the child called 'CLT' effectively illustrates the persistence of racism.
Language Bias
The language used is generally neutral and objective. The author uses strong but appropriate language to describe historical injustices and ongoing inequalities, but avoids inflammatory or overly emotional language. Words like "perversa" (perverse) are used to describe specific policies, reflecting a justified critical assessment rather than biased rhetoric.
Bias by Omission
The article focuses heavily on the contributions of Black workers in Brazil, but could benefit from mentioning the contributions of other marginalized groups to provide a more comprehensive picture of Brazilian labor history. Additionally, while it mentions the challenges faced by Black workers, a more detailed exploration of the systemic inequalities and ongoing struggles could strengthen the analysis.
Sustainable Development Goals
The article highlights the historical contributions of Black workers in Brazil, challenging the narrative of racial inequality and advocating for recognition of their role in building the nation. It also addresses the ongoing struggle against racial discrimination in the workplace, connecting directly to the SDG target of reducing inequalities and promoting social inclusion.