faz.net
Reimann's Final Cycle and the State of Contemporary Classical Music
A Berlin concert on July 24th, 2023, featured Aribert Reimann's final song cycle, "Überwundene Zeit," alongside his early works, contrasting established compositional mastery with the current trends in contemporary classical music, all performed one day after the 83rd birthday of poet Uwe Grüning, who died with Reimann within one week of each other in July 2022.
- How did the concert juxtapose Reimann's early and later works, revealing his artistic development and evolution?
- The concert's juxtaposition of Reimann's early works with the final song cycle underscored the themes of loss and acceptance, reflecting the deaths of both Reimann and Grüning within a week of each other in July 2022. Reimann's early works, including a violin sonata, showcased a mastery of form and expression, contrasting sharply with the more vague works of contemporary composers.
- What were the key themes explored in Aribert Reimann's final song cycle, and how did the concert program reflect the composers' recent deaths?
- Unzeitige Einsicht," a two-line poem by Uwe Grüning, served as the centerpiece of Aribert Reimann's final song cycle, "Überwundene Zeit," performed in Berlin on July 24th, 2023, a day after Grüning's 83rd birthday. The concert also featured Reimann's early works, highlighting his exceptional musical talent.
- What does the contrast between Reimann's compositional style and that of contemporary composers suggest about trends in contemporary classical music?
- The performance highlighted the stylistic differences between established composers like Reimann and contemporary composers, whose works were described as 'musical mumbling.' This contrast reveals a potential trend of declining musical complexity and expressive power in newer compositions, while also celebrating the enduring legacy of masters like Reimann.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The framing emphasizes the perceived decline in quality of contemporary music, contrasting it with the lauded works of older composers. This is evident in the opening paragraphs focusing on the emotional depth of the Reimann pieces and the later criticism of the 'vagueness' of younger composers' work. The headline, if any, would likely reinforce this contrast.
Language Bias
The article uses loaded language, such as 'musical nuscheln' (mumbling) to describe younger composers' work, which is a negative and subjective judgment. The use of terms like 'vagen' (vague) and 'verzagt' (timid) also carries negative connotations. More neutral alternatives could include 'experimental,' 'innovative,' or 'unconventional' instead of negative terms.
Bias by Omission
The article focuses heavily on the Ultraschall festival and specific composers, potentially omitting other relevant events or musical works from the same period. While acknowledging space constraints, the lack of broader context might limit the reader's understanding of the contemporary music scene.
False Dichotomy
The review sets up a false dichotomy between the 'musical nuscheln' of younger composers and the established works of older composers like Reimann. This simplifies the diversity of contemporary music and potentially undervalues innovative approaches within the younger generation.
Gender Bias
While the article mentions several female composers and performers (e.g., Younghi Pagh-Paan, Viviane Hagner, Anna Skryleva, Iris ter Schiphorst, Salome Kammer, Catherine Larsen-Maguire, and Felicitas Hoppe), there's no overt gender bias in the descriptions. However, a deeper analysis might reveal if certain aspects of their work or personal details are highlighted more than those of male artists.
Sustainable Development Goals
The article highlights the importance of music education and the impact of training and mentorship on young musicians. The success of young composers and performers showcased at the Ultraschall festival demonstrates the positive impact of quality education and training in the arts.