River Management and Flood Control: A Balancing Act

River Management and Flood Control: A Balancing Act

elpais.com

River Management and Flood Control: A Balancing Act

Experts discuss the detrimental effects of removing vegetation from riverbeds, advocating for nature-based solutions while acknowledging the need for hard infrastructure in certain cases.

Spanish
Spain
Climate ChangeEnvironmentInfrastructureFloodingInvasive SpeciesRivers
CreafUniversity Of ZaragozaConfederación Hidrográfica Del Júcar (Chj)Colegio De Ingenieros De CaminosCanales Y Puertos
Pau FortuñoAlfredo OlleroFederico Bonet
What are the effects of river channelization and what are better alternatives?
River channelization increases water speed and height, worsening flood damage. Widening riverbeds and removing artificial channels increases permeability and reduces flood risks.
What is the common misconception regarding vegetation in riverbeds and its impact on floods?
The belief that removing vegetation from riverbeds improves water flow during floods is false. Vegetation helps reduce water velocity and destructive power, and removing it increases the growth of invasive species.
Are nature-based solutions always the best approach to flood control, or are there exceptions?
While 'green' solutions using nature are preferable, they aren't always applicable. In some cases, hard infrastructure like dams or channelization may be necessary to mitigate flood risks.
What is the problem with invasive species like the common reed (Arundo donax) and how is it related to river management?
The common reed (Arundo donax) is an invasive species that causes problems due to its rapid growth. Removing native vegetation ironically promotes the growth of this and other invasive species.
What are the political and societal factors that contribute to the continued practice of stripping vegetation from riverbeds?
Maintaining riverbanks requires removing invasive species, but leaving native vegetation is crucial for flood control and water purification. Rapid, vote-seeking solutions often harm long-term river health.