kathimerini.gr
Russia Doubts New START Treaty Renewal Amid Deteriorating US Relations
Russia's Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov stated that the New START nuclear arms control treaty with the US is unlikely to be renewed due to poor relations, criticizing the US's 'Golden Dome' missile defense system; the treaty expires in eight months, potentially leading to a new arms race.
- What is the immediate impact of the anticipated failure to extend the New START treaty?
- Russia's Deputy Foreign Minister, Sergei Ryabkov, stated that the New START treaty, the last remaining nuclear arms control pact between Russia and the US, is unlikely to be extended due to severely deteriorated relations. The treaty is set to expire in eight months. Ryabkov also criticized the US's proposed 'Golden Dome' missile defense system as destabilizing.
- How does the proposed 'Golden Dome' missile defense system contribute to the strained US-Russia relationship and the potential for an arms race?
- Ryabkov's comments reflect a significant worsening in US-Russia relations, jeopardizing the New START treaty which limits both countries' strategic nuclear warheads. Failure to extend the treaty could trigger a new arms race, escalating existing tensions surrounding the war in Ukraine. The potential for a 60% increase in Russia's deployed nuclear arsenal if the treaty lapses is a serious concern.
- What are the long-term global security implications of a lapse in the New START treaty, considering the ongoing war in Ukraine and the potential for increased nuclear deployments?
- The 'Golden Dome' missile defense system, coupled with the breakdown of communication between the US and Russia, creates substantial obstacles to nuclear arms control. This situation underscores the increased risk of a global conflict and highlights the urgency for diplomatic solutions to prevent a new arms race and further escalation.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The article's framing emphasizes the negative consequences of the treaty's potential expiration, highlighting the warnings of experts and the potential for a new arms race. The headline (if there was one) and introductory sentences likely focus on the grim outlook from the Russian official's statements. This emphasis may unduly alarm the reader, while downplaying potential avenues for negotiation or compromise. The inclusion of the 'Gold Dome' anti-missile defense system adds to this negative framing, portraying it as an obstacle to arms control.
Language Bias
The language used, such as describing the relations between US and Russia as being "at their nadir" and the "Gold Dome" project as "highly destabilizing", leans towards negatively framing the situation. Words like "grim" and "fears" contribute to this negative tone. More neutral alternatives might include "strained" instead of "nadir", and "potentially destabilizing" instead of "highly destabilizing". The repeated emphasis on the potential for a new arms race also contributes to a sense of alarm.
Bias by Omission
The article focuses heavily on Russian perspectives and concerns regarding the New START treaty, omitting detailed counterarguments or perspectives from the US side. While it mentions US support for Ukraine as a point of contention, it lacks a nuanced exploration of the US rationale and potential compromises. The article also omits discussion of other arms control treaties or initiatives that might offer alternative paths forward, focusing solely on the New START treaty. This limited scope, while possibly due to space constraints, could potentially mislead the reader into believing the issue is entirely one-sided.
False Dichotomy
The article presents a somewhat false dichotomy by framing the situation as either the New START treaty being extended or a new arms race inevitably occurring. It doesn't fully explore the possibility of alternative agreements or less drastic outcomes. The potential for diplomatic solutions or modifications to the existing treaty is underrepresented.
Gender Bias
The article primarily quotes male political figures (Putin, Ryabkov, Trump). There is no mention of female perspectives or voices from either US or Russian governments or expert communities on arms control. This absence of female voices creates an unbalanced narrative.
Sustainable Development Goals
The potential collapse of the New START treaty increases the risk of a new arms race, undermining international peace and security. Russia's suspension of participation and the US development of the Golden Dome missile defense system further exacerbate tensions and hinder efforts towards disarmament and arms control. This directly impacts SDG 16 (Peace, Justice and Strong Institutions) by increasing global instability and threatening international cooperation on crucial security issues.