dw.com
Scholz-Putin Call Sparks Controversy
German Chancellor Scholz's phone call with Putin sparks controversy, with critics viewing it as a sign of weakness while supporters emphasize diplomatic efforts.
Russian
Germany
PoliticsRussiaGermany Russia Ukraine WarUkraineDiplomacy
Cdu/CsuSpdNatoKremlinBundestag
Olaf ScholzVladimir PutinJürgen HardtMatthias MierschVladimir Zelensky
- How did different political figures in Germany respond to the phone call?
- Jürgen Hardt, a CDU/CSU member of the Bundestag, argued that the Kremlin only understands "signals of strength," such as threats of increased military aid to Ukraine. He believes Scholz's call was primarily for domestic political reasons, aiming to show commitment to dialogue. Conversely, Matthias Miersch, the SPD general secretary, defended Scholz, emphasizing the importance of diplomatic efforts to end the war.
- What were the key points discussed during the phone call between Scholz and Putin?
- The phone call, the first since December 2022, saw Scholz condemn the war in Ukraine, urge a Russian withdrawal, and stress the need for negotiations. Putin, in response, cited NATO's actions and maintained that Russia remained open to talks. Ukraine's President Zelensky criticized the call, suggesting it undermined efforts to isolate Putin.
- What is the broader political context surrounding the differing opinions on the phone call?
- The differing opinions highlight a debate within Germany about the appropriate approach to Russia. While some see dialogue as crucial for a peaceful resolution, others believe it signals weakness and undermines efforts to isolate Russia. This disagreement reflects the complex political landscape surrounding the war in Ukraine.
- What were the main criticisms of German Chancellor Scholz's phone call with Vladimir Putin?
- German Chancellor Olaf Scholz's recent phone call with Russian President Vladimir Putin has sparked controversy. A CDU/CSU expert criticized the call, viewing it as a sign of weakness that gives Putin a propaganda victory. However, Scholz's party defended the call's importance for diplomatic progress.
- What were the specific concerns raised regarding Scholz's approach to the conversation with Putin?
- Scholz's conversation with Putin included calls for a Russian troop withdrawal from Ukraine and the need for negotiations toward a just and lasting peace. However, the lack of concrete proposals and Scholz's failure to issue an ultimatum concerned critics like Hardt, who found the call to be politically damaging. Bild also reported that Scholz had notified allies of his plans well in advance.