dailymail.co.uk
South African Mother Charged with Selling Missing Daughter to Traditional Healer
In February 2024, six-year-old Joshlin Smith vanished from her Saldanha Bay, South Africa home; her mother Kelly Smith, boyfriend, and friend are accused of selling her to a traditional healer for approximately \$1,100 due to her light eyes and skin; the healer was initially arrested but released due to insufficient evidence, and the suspects face life imprisonment if convicted.
- What are the immediate consequences of the accusations against Kelly Smith and her associates regarding Joshlin's disappearance?
- A six-year-old girl, Joshlin Smith, disappeared in Saldanha Bay, South Africa, in February 2024. Her mother, Kelly Smith, along with her boyfriend and a friend, have been charged with kidnapping and human trafficking, accused of selling Joshlin to a traditional healer for approximately \$1,100. The healer allegedly sought Joshlin for her light eyes and skin.
- What role did the traditional healer ('sangoma') play in Joshlin's disappearance, and what legal challenges arose in their prosecution?
- The case highlights the disturbing practice of child trafficking for traditional healing purposes in South Africa. Neighbor testimonies and recovered children's clothing with bloodstains suggest Joshlin was sold to a "sangoma", a traditional healer, who was initially arrested but later released due to insufficient evidence. The ongoing search involves police and community members.
- What are the long-term implications of this case for child protection laws and practices in South Africa, and how might this affect future investigations into similar crimes?
- The trial's outcome will significantly impact future child protection measures in South Africa. If convicted, the suspects face life imprisonment, potentially deterring similar crimes. The case underscores the need for increased awareness and stricter law enforcement against the exploitation of children in traditional healing practices. The lack of evidence leading to the release of the sangoma highlights the challenges in prosecuting such cases.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The framing emphasizes the mother's alleged role in the kidnapping and the gruesome details surrounding the potential crime, such as the blood-stained clothing and knife, potentially prejudicing readers against her before the trial concludes. The headline, while factual, focuses on the mother's alleged actions, placing that information at the forefront. The sequence of events presented also contributes to the emphasis on Kelly's alleged culpability. Although the article mentions the not-guilty pleas, this is overshadowed by the weight of the other presented evidence.
Language Bias
The language used is generally neutral, however phrases like "gruesome details" and "high-profile search mission" could be considered slightly loaded. The descriptions of Joshlin's appearance ("fair complexion and turquoise eyes") are factual but could contribute to an implicit focus on her physical characteristics, possibly drawing attention to those features in a way that would not be done for a child with different features. More neutral alternatives for some of the descriptions could be used. For example, instead of 'gruesome details,' a more neutral term such as 'details of the evidence' could be used.
Bias by Omission
The article omits the specific details about the sangoma's alleged motive for wanting a child with light eyes and skin. While it mentions the sangoma's belief in ancestral spirits, it doesn't explain the connection between this belief and the desire for a child with these specific features. This omission leaves a significant gap in understanding the full context of the crime. Additionally, the article doesn't elaborate on the specifics of the forensic examination of the clothing and knife found near the family home. The lack of detail prevents readers from forming a fully informed opinion about the evidence in the case. While there are likely constraints due to the ongoing investigation and the need to avoid compromising the case, more details could provide a more complete picture.
Gender Bias
The article focuses on the mother's actions and motivations, while mentioning other suspects without the same level of detail. There is an emphasis on her alleged confession, and her personal life (number of children) is included. There is no equivalent focus on the personal details of the male suspects. However, given the nature of the crime and the central role of the mother, the gendered details provided do not seem inherently biased, though more context on the male suspect's lives may lead to a fairer balance.
Sustainable Development Goals
The case highlights the failure to protect a vulnerable child, indicating weaknesses in law enforcement and the justice system. The ongoing search and trial process are attempts to address these failures and uphold justice. The crime itself is a direct violation of the rule of law and basic human rights.