![Spiegelman and Sacco on the Gaza War: "Never Again and Again](/img/article-image-placeholder.webp)
faz.net
Spiegelman and Sacco on the Gaza War: "Never Again and Again
Art Spiegelman and Joe Sacco's three-page comic "Never Again and Again," published last week in the New York Review of Books, depicts their conversation about the 2023 Gaza War, expressing their anguish and contrasting perspectives on the conflict's resolution.
- How do the distinct artistic styles and personal experiences of Spiegelman and Sacco shape their portrayal of the 2023 Gaza War, and what are the implications of this for interpreting the conflict?
- The comic serves as a commentary on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, specifically the 2023 war, offering a poignant reflection on the violence and the seemingly intractable nature of the conflict. It builds upon Sacco's online series, "The War on Gaza," which focuses on the horrors of the Israeli military response. Spiegelman's contribution introduces allegorical elements, illustrating the challenges faced by both sides.
- What are the central arguments presented in Spiegelman and Sacco's "Never Again and Again" regarding the 2023 Gaza War, and what immediate implications do these arguments hold for understanding the conflict?
- Never Again and Again," a three-page comic by Art Spiegelman and Joe Sacco published in the New York Review of Books, depicts their conversation about the 2023 Gaza War. The comic features Spiegelman's characteristic Maus persona and Sacco's distinct style, reflecting their differing yet equally critical perspectives on the conflict.
- What are the longer-term implications of the pessimistic outlook presented in "Never Again and Again," and what potential solutions or approaches to resolving the Israeli-Palestinian conflict are either explicitly or implicitly suggested?
- The comic's pessimistic outlook suggests a deep sense of hopelessness regarding the conflict's resolution. The authors' shared anguish and contrasting viewpoints highlight the complexity of the issue, suggesting that a lasting peace requires perspectives beyond their own. The inclusion of antisemitic imagery alongside critiques of Israeli actions raises questions about the representation of the conflict and potential pitfalls in communicating complex political realities.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The narrative frames the conflict primarily through the lens of the Israeli military actions and their impact, particularly focusing on the suffering within Israel. The headline, while not explicitly provided, is inferred to emphasize the artists' reactions to the conflict, potentially overshadowing the broader context of the war. The introductory paragraphs emphasize the artists' perspectives and the graphic novel, giving prominence to this specific analysis of the conflict rather than presenting a balanced overview of the events.
Language Bias
The language used, while generally neutral in tone, displays a subtle bias in the descriptions and emphasis placed on certain aspects of the conflict. For instance, terms like "drastic characterizations" in reference to Sacco's depiction of Israeli leaders could be interpreted as loaded. The description of Netanyahu's depiction as utilizing "antisemitic cliché" suggests a critical perspective.
Bias by Omission
The analysis focuses heavily on the Israeli perspective of the conflict, potentially omitting or downplaying the Palestinian perspective and experiences. The article mentions Hamas's actions but spends significantly more time detailing the Israeli response and its consequences. While acknowledging practical constraints of length, the lack of balanced representation of both sides constitutes a bias by omission.
False Dichotomy
The article presents a somewhat false dichotomy by implicitly framing the conflict as solely between Israel and Hamas, neglecting the complexities of the situation involving various factions and historical grievances. The discussion of a 'just solution' also implicitly suggests a single solution exists, ignoring the range of possible outcomes and perspectives.
Sustainable Development Goals
The comic "Never Again and Again" depicts the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, focusing on the suffering caused by the war and the lack of a just solution. The authors express anguish and hopelessness, highlighting the failure of institutions to achieve peace and justice in the region. The depiction of Israeli actions, while acknowledging Hamas's role, criticizes Israeli policies and their impact on Palestinians. The inclusion of antisemitic tropes, albeit unintentionally, further complicates the issue and underscores the challenges to achieving peace and justice.