faz.net
Spiegelman and Sacco's Comic Critiques Gaza War
Art Spiegelman and Joe Sacco's "Never Again and Again," a three-page comic in the New York Review of Books, critiques Israeli actions in the 2023 Gaza War, expressing their despair over the conflict's complexities and the lack of a just solution.
- How does the graphic style of "Never Again and Again" contribute to the authors' message, and how does it compare to Sacco's previous work on the Gaza conflict?
- The comic juxtaposes Spiegelman's and Sacco's views, highlighting disagreements on Hamas's potential actions with equal resources and showcasing their shared despair over the conflict. Spiegelman's section allegorically criticizes Israeli settlement policies.
- What are the central arguments presented by Spiegelman and Sacco in "Never Again and Again," and how do these critiques reflect broader concerns about the Gaza conflict?
- Never Again and Again," a three-page comic by Art Spiegelman and Joe Sacco published in the New York Review of Books, depicts their conversation about the 2023 Gaza War. The comic, an extension of Sacco's "The War on Gaza" series, critiques Israeli military actions and explores the complexities of the conflict from their perspectives.
- What are the long-term implications of the perspectives shared in "Never Again and Again," and how might this work influence public discourse on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict?
- The work's impact lies in its unique perspective from two prominent political cartoonists. Their shared disillusionment reflects the global concern over the humanitarian crisis and the stalemate in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. The graphic depiction of Netanyahu and Biden further emphasizes the authors' critical stance.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The framing of the narrative centers around the perspectives of Spiegelman and Sacco, both of whom express significant criticism towards Israeli actions. This positioning shapes the reader's understanding by emphasizing the negative aspects of Israeli military operations and the despair felt by the authors. The headline itself, "Never Again and Again," evokes the Holocaust and implies a repetition of past atrocities, potentially framing the Israeli actions as genocidal or equivalent to historical atrocities.
Language Bias
The review uses strong language to describe Netanyahu ("grüngesichtigen Netanjahu in nosferatuähnlicher Pose") and implies that Israeli actions are similar to those of the Holocaust. While this reflects the authors' opinions, it could be seen as using loaded language, particularly the comparison to Nosferatu and antisemitic stereotypes, which influences the reader's perception. Neutral alternatives would focus on factual descriptions of actions and policy rather than subjective characterizations.
Bias by Omission
The analysis focuses heavily on the Israeli perspective of the conflict, potentially omitting crucial Palestinian voices and experiences. While the Hamas attack is acknowledged, the narrative largely centers on the consequences of the Israeli response, potentially downplaying Palestinian suffering and the reasons behind the initial attack. The limited scope of a three-page comic may be a contributing factor, but this omission still leaves a significant gap in understanding the conflict's multifaceted nature.
False Dichotomy
The comic seems to present a false dichotomy by primarily focusing on the suffering caused by the Israeli military response while giving less attention to the suffering caused by the Hamas attack and the broader political context. This creates a simplified view of the conflict, neglecting the complexities and multiple perspectives involved.
Sustainable Development Goals
The comic "Never Again and Again" depicts the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, highlighting the ongoing violence and the lack of a peaceful resolution. The authors express despair and hopelessness regarding the situation, indicating a negative impact on peace and justice. The portrayal of Israeli actions and the critique of Israeli policies directly relate to the lack of strong institutions capable of maintaining peace and upholding justice in the region.