edition.cnn.com
Supreme Court Remands Death Row Inmate's Case
The Supreme Court remanded the case of death row inmate Joseph Smith back to a lower court for reconsideration of his intellectual disability claim, highlighting the ongoing debate surrounding intellectual disability and capital punishment.
English
United States
Human Rights ViolationsUs PoliticsSupreme CourtDeath PenaltyCapital PunishmentLegal CaseIntellectual Disability
Supreme Court11Th Us Circuit Court Of Appeals
Joseph SmithClarence ThomasNeil GorsuchDurk Van DamRichard Glossip
- What is the central legal question in Smith's case?
- Smith's IQ scores were just above the threshold for intellectual disability, leading to debate about whether other factors should be considered. The 11th Circuit Court of Appeals instructed a lower court to examine additional factors beyond IQ scores.
- What details of the crime are relevant to Smith's appeal?
- The case involves conflicting versions of the crime and the brutality of the murder, adding to the legal complexities surrounding Smith's conviction and sentence. The state claimed Smith brutally beat the victim to steal a small amount of money and some tools.
- How did Justices Thomas and Gorsuch respond to the Supreme Court's decision?
- Justices Thomas and Gorsuch dissented, preferring to hear the case immediately. The Supreme Court's decision to remand highlights the complexity of the case and the justices' differing opinions.
- What action did the Supreme Court take regarding the case of death row inmate Joseph Smith?
- The Supreme Court sent the case of Joseph Smith, an Alabama death row inmate, back to a lower court for reconsideration. The issue is whether lower courts correctly determined Smith's intellectual disability, impacting his death penalty eligibility.
- What is the significance of the Supreme Court's 2002 ruling on executing intellectually disabled inmates?
- The Supreme Court's 2002 ruling prohibits executing intellectually disabled inmates, but determining the line between disabled and non-disabled remains challenging due to the inherent variability in IQ testing.