lexpress.fr
The Housing Tax Fiasco in France
Analysis of the economic and political ramifications of abolishing France's housing tax, and proposed solutions for more efficient local government funding.
French
France
Labour MarketFranceGovernment SpendingFrench EconomyTax ReformFiscal ResponsibilityPolitical Decision
French GovernmentMacron's Presidential Campaign
Emmanuel MacronFrançois FillonEric CoquerelJean-François Copé
- Why was the French housing tax abolished?
- The abolition of the housing tax in France was primarily a political move, deemed necessary to boost Macron's approval ratings during the 2017 presidential campaign, despite its negative economic consequences.
- What were the main economic consequences of abolishing the housing tax?
- Eliminating the tax resulted in a significant loss of revenue for French municipalities, approximately \u20ac15 billion annually, forcing them to compensate through increased property taxes and reduced services. This also led to increased national deficit.
- What alternative system of taxation is suggested as a long-term solution?
- A "shared taxation" system, similar to models in the US, Canada, and Switzerland, could provide greater autonomy to local governments while enabling fiscal competition between regions, potentially incentivizing more efficient governance.
- How did the French government handle the financial implications of this decision?
- The lack of equivalent spending cuts to offset the tax reduction exemplifies France's tendency to disregard deficit concerns. This irresponsible fiscal approach necessitates future tax increases or spending cuts to rectify the imbalance.
- What are some potential solutions to address the issues arising from the tax abolition?
- A proposed solution involves reinstating the housing tax; however, the current political climate renders this unlikely. A more viable long-term solution involves reforming France's territorial organization and local government funding.