bbc.com
This City Is Ours": Liverpool Gang Drama Explores Modern Masculinity
This City Is Ours," a new BBC drama, follows Liverpool gang member Michael Kavanagh (James Nelson-Joyce) as he navigates a power struggle within his criminal organization while simultaneously trying to start a family through IVF with his partner, against the backdrop of evolving views of modern masculinity.
- How does the setting of Liverpool influence the narrative and character development in the show?
- The show uses the framework of a crime drama to explore themes of modern masculinity, contrasting the traditional image of a powerful gang member with the vulnerability of wanting a family. Michael's internal conflict reflects broader societal changes in expectations of men, showcasing the tension between traditional roles and personal desires. The setting in Liverpool adds a unique cultural dimension.
- What are the key themes explored in "This City Is Ours", and how do they reflect contemporary societal issues?
- This City Is Ours", a new BBC drama, features James Nelson-Joyce as Michael Kavanagh, a gang member balancing crime and family life. His character's struggle with low sperm count and pursuit of IVF alongside his criminal activities highlights the complexities of modern masculinity. The show explores the power struggle within the gang as Michael vies for control against Ronnie Phelan's son.
- What are the potential long-term impacts of this show's portrayal of masculinity on viewers' perceptions and expectations of men?
- This City Is Ours" offers a fresh perspective on crime dramas by focusing on the emotional complexities of its characters. By intertwining the high-stakes criminal world with intimate family struggles, the series challenges conventional portrayals of masculinity and explores the consequences of societal pressures on individual lives. The show's success could inspire similar productions that delve deeper into complex character dynamics within crime narratives.
Cognitive Concepts
Framing Bias
The framing emphasizes the actor's performance and personal life, potentially overshadowing other aspects of the show. The comparison to 'The Sopranos' sets a particular expectation. The positive quotes from the creator and director further shape the narrative toward a favorable review.
Language Bias
The language is mostly positive and enthusiastic, using terms like "amazing," "gift," and "brilliant." While this conveys the reviewer's opinion, it lacks objectivity. Examples include describing the actor as a "rising star" and mentioning his potential as James Bond, which are subjective opinions rather than factual statements. The comparison to "The Sopranos" could be considered loaded language, influencing readers' expectations.
Bias by Omission
The review focuses heavily on the main actor and the show's production, giving less attention to other characters and plot points. While this is understandable given space constraints, it omits a more comprehensive view of the series' themes and narrative depth. The lack of detailed plot summary beyond the main conflict might mislead viewers unfamiliar with the premise.
Gender Bias
The review focuses primarily on the male characters and their conflicts, with Diana's role described mainly in relation to the male protagonist's personal growth. More balanced representation of female characters and their agency within the plot would be beneficial.
Sustainable Development Goals
The show challenges traditional masculinity by portraying a male character who embraces vulnerability and emotional depth, promoting healthier representations of manhood and challenging gender stereotypes. The character's journey towards a loving partnership and desire for family life directly counters harmful stereotypes.